动物疾病管理中疫苗使用相关的风险补偿与溢出行为适应评估
本文分析农民对政府通过接种獾疫苗减少獾至牛疾病传播风险举措的行为反应,检验风险补偿与溢出效应两种对立行为适应。研究使用英格兰5个地区农民对獾疫苗接种预防牛结核病态度、生物安全实践报告及牛只移动数据的纵向混合方法研究,其中1个地区经历獾疫苗接种。分析发现疫苗接种后溢出行为证据有限,风险补偿行为与农民对谁应管理动物疾病的信念相关。
要点
- 獾疫苗接种后溢出行为证据有限。
- 溢出缺乏归因于农民对生物安全有效性的信念及獾疫苗与其他动物疫苗缺乏相似性。
- 风险补偿行为与农民对谁应管理动物疾病的信念相关。
核心结论
- 分析发现獾疫苗接种后溢出行为证据有限;风险补偿行为与农民对谁应管理动物疾病的信念相关,而非农民对疫苗有效性的信念。
- 农民对自身预防疾病能力感低更可能影响其表面风险补偿行为。
研究设计与样本
- 纵向混合方法研究,使用英格兰5个地区农民对獾疫苗接种预防牛结核病态度、生物安全实践报告及牛只移动数据,其中1个地区经历獾疫苗接种。
主要发现
- 分析发现獾疫苗接种后溢出行为证据有限。
- 溢出缺乏归因于农民对生物安全有效性的信念及獾疫苗与其他动物疫苗缺乏相似性。
- 风险补偿行为与农民对谁应管理动物疾病的信念相关。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
This paper analyses farmers' behavioural responses to Government attempts to reduce the risk of disease transmission from badgers to cattle through badger vaccination. Evidence for two opposing behavioural adaptions is examined in response to the vaccination of badgers to reduce the risk of transmission to farmed cattle. Risk compensation theory suggests that interventions that reduce risk, such as vaccination, are counterbalanced by negative behavioural adaptions. By contrast, the spillover effect suggests that interventions can prompt further positive behaviours. The paper uses data from a longitudinal mixed methods study of farmers' attitudes to badger vaccination to prevent the spread of bovine tuberculosis, their reports of biosecurity practices, and cattle movement data in 5 areas of England, one of which experienced badger vaccination. Analysis finds limited evidence of spillover behaviours following vaccination. Lack of spillover is attributed to farmers' beliefs in the effectiveness of biosecurity and the lack of similarity between badger vaccination and vaccination for other animal diseases. Risk compensation behaviours are associated with farmers' beliefs as to who should manage animal disease. Rather than farmers' belief in vaccine effectiveness, it is more likely that farmers' low sense of being able to do anything to prevent disease influences their apparent risk compensation behaviours. These findings address the gap in the literature relating to farmers' behavioural adaptions to vaccine use in the management of animal disease.
引用
- Enticott G, Maye D, Naylor R, et al. An assessment of risk compensation and spillover behavioural adaptions associated with the use of vaccines in animal disease management. Vaccine. 2019. PMID: 31813650. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2019.11.037
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。