加纳四个地区医护人员报告免疫接种后不良事件的障碍
研究对加纳四个地区169家卫生机构的306名医护人员进行横断面调查,发现曾遇到免疫接种后不良事件(AEFI)的120人中仅55.0%报告、31.7%填写报告表;主要障碍为担心个人后果(44.1%)、缺乏知识或培训(25.2%)及不认为AEFI足够严重(22.2%);上一年度督导访视中讨论AEFI与报告显著相关(OR 7.39;p < .001)。
要点
- 120名过去一年遇到AEFI的医护人员中,66人(55.0%)报告,38人(31.7%)填写报告表。
- 最常见报告障碍为担心个人后果(44.1%)、缺乏知识或培训(25.2%)及不认为AEFI足够严重(22.2%)。
- 督导访视中讨论AEFI与过去一年报告显著相关(OR 7.39;p < .001)。
核心结论
- 加纳四个选定地区医护人员AEFI报告率低且存在多种报告障碍。
- 作者认为督导访视中与医护人员讨论AEFI可能改善报告。
- 作者认为需要制定策略以解决担心个人后果这一报告障碍。
研究设计与样本
- 在加纳四个地区开展横断面调查,简单随机抽取176家卫生机构,每家机构随机抽取至多2名医护人员。
- 共访谈169家机构的306名医护人员,每家机构另访谈1名负责AEFI报告与管理的督导。
- 采用Rao-Scott卡方检验比较过去一年AEFI报告相关因素,并用开放式问题识别报告率低的原因。
主要发现
- 306名医护人员中,176人(57.5%)表示曾遇到AEFI。
- 过去一年遇到AEFI的120人中,66人(55.0%)表示已报告,38人(31.7%)填写了报告表。
- 医护人员(n = 120)报告多种报告障碍,最常见为担心个人后果(44.1%)、缺乏知识或培训(25.2%)及不认为AEFI足够严重(22.2%)。
- 督导访视中讨论AEFI与过去一年报告显著相关(OR 7.39;p < .001)。
- 172名受访督导中,65人(37.8%)提到其机构曾遇到AEFI;超过90%的机构有报告表。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为督导访视中与医护人员讨论AEFI可能改善报告。
- 作者认为需要制定策略以解决担心个人后果这一报告障碍。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Despite didactic training on adverse events following immunization (AEFI) in Ghana, the reporting ratio of AEFI was 1.56 per 100,000 surviving infants in 2015, below the minimum reporting ratio of 10. We aimed to estimate the proportion of health care workers (HCWs) reporting AEFI and to identify barriers to reporting. We conducted a cross-sectional survey of HCWs in four regions in Ghana. A simple random sample of 176 health facilities was selected and up to two HCWs were randomly selected per facility. We used the Rao-Scott Chi-squared test to compare factors associated with reporting of AEFI in the last year. We used an open-ended question to identify reasons for low reporting. One supervisor from each facility, responsible for overall reporting and management of AEFI, was also interviewed. A total of 306 HCWs from 169 facilities were interviewed. Of these, 176 (57.5%) reported they had ever encountered an AEFI. Of the 120 who had encountered an AEFI in the last year, 66 (55.0%) indicated they had reported the AEFI, and 38 (31.7%) completed a reporting form. HCWs (n = 120) reported multiple barriers to reporting of AEFI; the most common barriers were fear of personal consequences (44.1%), lack of knowledge or training (25.2%), and not believing an AEFI was serious enough to report (22.2%). Discussion of AEFI during the last supervisory visit was significantly associated with reporting in the past year (OR 7.39; p < .001). Of 172 supervisors interviewed, 65 (37.8%) mentioned their facilties had ever encountered an AEFI; over 90% of facilities had reporting forms. We identified low reporting of AEFI and multiple barriers to reporting among HCWs in the four selected regions of Ghana. Discussing AEFI during supervisory visits with HCWs might improve reporting. Additionally, strategies to address fear of personal consequences as a barrier to reporting of AEFI are needed.
引用
- Gidudu JF, Shaum A, Dodoo A, et al. Barriers to healthcare workers reporting adverse events following immunization in four regions of Ghana. Vaccine. 2019. PMID: 31787409. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2019.11.050
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。