流感疫苗接种回音室中的回声:选择性注意胜过社会影响
该实验从1859名MTurk参与者中预选208名对流感疫苗接种持消极态度者和221名持积极态度者,组成同质或异质的3人链式实验扩散链,评估参与者传递的疫苗信息、 incoming消息对疫苗相关认知的改变及对信息的感知。结果显示参与者选择性传递态度一致的信息但无整体反疫苗偏见,不愿因消息改变认知,且认为与先前态度一致的信息更有说服力。讨论指出流感疫苗相关认知对矛盾和偏见性在线沟通具有韧性,未发现在线沟通放大反疫苗态度。
要点
- 参与者选择性传递与自身态度一致的流感疫苗信息,但未表现出整体反疫苗偏见。
- 参与者不愿因 incoming 消息改变其流感疫苗相关认知。
- 参与者认为与先前态度一致的信息更具说服力,认知对矛盾信息有韧性。
核心结论
- 流感疫苗相关认知对矛盾和偏见性在线沟通具有韧性,未发现在线沟通放大反疫苗态度。
研究设计与样本
- 实验从1859名MTurk参与者中预选208名对流感疫苗接种持消极态度者和221名持积极态度者,分入同质或异质的3人链式实验扩散链。
主要发现
- 参与者选择性传递态度一致的信息,但未表现出整体反疫苗偏见。
- 参与者不愿因 incoming 消息改变其流感疫苗相关认知。
- 参与者认为与先前态度一致的信息更具说服力。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Online discussions may impact the willingness to get vaccinated. This experiment tests how groups of individuals with consistent and inconsistent attitudes towards flu vaccination attend to and convey information online, and how they alter their corresponding risk perceptions. METHODS: Out of 1859 MTurkers, we pre-selected 208 people with negative and 221 people with positive attitudes towards flu vaccinations into homogeneous or heterogeneous 3-link experimental diffusion chains. We assessed (i) which information about flu vaccinations participants conveyed to the subsequent link, (ii) how flu-vaccination related perceptions were altered by incoming messages, and (iii) how participants perceived incoming information. RESULTS: Participants (i) selectively conveyed attitude-consistent information, but exhibited no overall anti-vaccination bias, (ii) were reluctant to alter their flu-vaccination related perceptions in response to messages, and (iii) evaluated incoming information consistent with their prior attitudes as more convincing. DISCUSSION: Flu-vaccination related perceptions are resilient against contradictions and bias online communication. Contrary to expectations, there was no sign of amplification of anti-vaccine attitudes by online communication.
引用
- Giese H, Neth H, Moussaïd M, et al. The echo in flu-vaccination echo chambers: Selective attention trumps social influence. Vaccine. 2019. PMID: 31864854. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2019.11.038
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。