文献速递卫生政策与健康促进传染病防控与疫情报告

西非无人机系统与摩托车运送实验室样本的比较经济学研究

Uncrewed aircraft systems versus motorcycles to deliver laboratory samples in west Africa: a comparative economic study.
PubMed 文献 · Lancet Glob Health · 2020-01-01

该研究比较了利比里亚无人机系统(UAS)与摩托车运送实验室样本的成本和成本效果,涵盖常规与公共卫生应急场景。常规场景下摩托车每样本运送成本为0.65美元(95%CI 0.01-2.85),UAS65为0.82美元(0.56-5.05)。作者认为在当前技术、采购价格、设备寿命和航程下,UAS不是西非常规样本运送的可行选择。

要点

  • 常规场景下摩托车每样本运送成本为0.65美元(95%CI 0.01-2.85),UAS65为0.82美元(0.56-5.05)。
  • 应急场景下摩托车每样本运送成本为24.06美元(95%CI 21.14-28.20),调整后UAS加补充摩托车模型为34.09美元(26.70-127.40)。
  • 摩托车比短程UAS(UAS30)更具成本效果,但随着航程和运行寿命增加,UAS成本效果逐渐提高。

核心结论

  • 基于当前技术水平、采购价格、设备寿命和运行航程,UAS不是西非常规实验室样本运送的可行选择。
  • 需要现场研究来产生关于UAS寿命、故障率以及在不同天气条件和载荷下性能的证据。

研究设计与样本

  • 比较经济学研究,比较UAS与摩托车在利比里亚运送实验室样本的成本和成本效果。
  • 模拟常规条件和基于2013-16年西非埃博拉病毒病疫情的公共卫生应急条件。
  • 建模三种UAS(UAS30、UAS65、UAS100,运行范围分别为30 km、65 km、100 km),寿命1000至10000小时。
  • 与利比里亚卫生部和慈善机构Riders for Health最常用的摩托车运送方案比较成本和运送样本数量。
  • UAS数据来自Skyfire、Vayu和Sandia National Laboratories,摩托车运行数据来自Riders for Health。

主要发现

  • 常规场景下,摩托车和UAS65的每样本运送成本分别为0.65美元(95%CI 0.01-2.85)和0.82美元(0.56-5.05)。
  • 应急场景下,摩托车每样本运送成本为24.06美元(95%CI 21.14-28.20)。
  • 应急场景下,地理覆盖不足的未调整UAS模型每样本运送成本为27.42美元(95%CI 19.25-136.75)。
  • 应急场景下,调整后UAS加补充摩托车模型每样本运送成本为34.09美元(95%CI 26.70-127.40)。
  • 摩托车比短程UAS(即UAS30)更具成本效果,但随着航程和运行寿命增加,UAS成本效果逐渐提高。

关键数值与推荐

  • 常规场景每样本运送成本:摩托车0.65美元(95%CI 0.01-2.85),UAS65为0.82美元(0.56-5.05)。
  • 应急场景每样本运送成本:摩托车24.06美元(95%CI 21.14-28.20)。
  • 应急场景每样本运送成本:未调整UAS模型27.42美元(95%CI 19.25-136.75)。
  • 应急场景每样本运送成本:调整后UAS加补充摩托车模型34.09美元(95%CI 26.70-127.40)。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 需要现场研究来产生关于UAS寿命、故障率以及在不同天气条件和载荷下性能的证据。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Transportation of laboratory samples in low-income and middle-income countries is often constrained by poor road conditions, difficult geographical terrain, and insecurity. These constraints can lead to long turnaround times for laboratory diagnostic tests and hamper epidemic control or patient treatment efforts. Although uncrewed aircraft systems (UAS)-ie, drones-can mitigate some of these transportation constraints, their cost-effectiveness compared with land-based transportation systems is unclear. METHODS: We did a comparative economic study of the costs and cost-effectiveness of UAS versus motorcycles in Liberia (west Africa) for transportation of laboratory samples under simulated routine conditions and public health emergency conditions (based on the 2013-16 west African Ebola virus disease epidemic). We modelled three UAS with operational ranges of 30 km, 65 km, and 100 km (UAS30, UAS65, and UAS100) and lifespans of 1000 to 10 000 h, and compared the costs and number of samples transported with an established motorcycle transportation programme (most commonly used by the Liberian Ministry of Health and the charity Riders for Health). Data for UAS were obtained from Skyfire (a UAS consultancy), Vayu (a UAS manufacturer), and Sandia National Laboratories (a private company with UAS research experience). Motorcycle operational data were obtained from Riders for Health. In our model, we included costs for personnel, equipment, maintenance, and training, and did univariate and probabilistic sensitivity analyses for UAS lifespans, range, and accident or failures. FINDINGS: Under the routine scenario, the per sample transport costs were US$0·65 (95% CI 0·01-2·85) and $0·82 (0·56-5·05) for motorcycles and UAS65, respectively. Per-sample transport costs under the emergency scenario were $24·06 (95% CI 21·14-28·20) for motorcycles, $27·42 (95% CI 19·25-136·75) for an unadjusted UAS model with insufficient geographical coverage, and $34·09 (95% CI 26·70-127·40) for an adjusted UAS model with complementary motorcycles. Motorcycles were more cost-effective than short-range UAS (ie, UAS30). However, with increasing range and operational lifespans, UAS became increasingly more cost-effective. INTERPRETATION: Given the current level of technology, purchase prices, equipment lifespans, and operational flying ranges, UAS are not a viable option for routine transport of laboratory samples in west Africa. Field studies are required to generate evidence about UAS lifespan, failure rates, and performance under different weather conditions and payloads. FUNDING: None.

来源:Lancet Glob Health,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Ochieng WO, Ye T, Scheel C, et al. Uncrewed aircraft systems versus motorcycles to deliver laboratory samples in west Africa: a comparative economic study. Lancet Glob Health. 2020. PMID: 31839129. doi:10.1016/S2214-109X(19)30464-4

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。