一年级医学生对手续强制性婴儿疫苗的认知与疫苗接种信任:培训未来医护人员的机遇窗口
法国2019年1月起实施疫苗强制政策,为评估医学生疫苗接种态度,对26所大学的PACES一年级学生进行匿名在线问卷调查,共4326人完成。学生对疫苗有用性中位评分90、有害性25、信任度82,多数认为强制接种在道德和科学上合理(65.7%和84.7%),但积极认知随年龄(17至21岁)下降。
要点
- 4326名PACES一年级学生完成问卷,年龄18.7±1.5岁,女性76.1%。
- 疫苗有用性、有害性、信任度中位评分分别为90、25、82。
- 65.7%和84.7%认为强制接种在道德和科学上合理,比例随年龄下降。
核心结论
- 一年级学生对疫苗接种和近期强制疫苗政策的认知是积极的,但年龄更小者更好,提示应尽早在此学年教授疫苗接种知识。
- 强制疫苗政策可能不会改善高度疫苗犹豫者的认知。
研究设计与样本
- 向提供PACES课程的35所法国大学发放匿名在线问卷,26所同意参与,共4326名一年级医学生完成。
主要发现
- 参与者年龄18.7±1.5岁,女性占76.1%。
- 疫苗有用性中位评分90(IQT 80-100),有害性中位评分25(IQT 10-50),疫苗信任度中位评分82(IQT 70-94)。
- 在17至21岁的五个主要年龄组中,对疫苗接种的积极认知随年龄增长而下降。
- 65.7%认为强制接种在道德上合理,84.7%认为在科学上合理;面对反强制接种广告牌,52.3%强烈不同意,28.6%较不同意,这些比例在17至21岁间下降。
- 对疫苗接种认知较差者,更不可能积极回答强制疫苗政策是否会改善其认知。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,疫苗接种应尽早教授,即在此学年期间。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: A high level of vaccine hesitancy is observed in France; to maintain a high level of vaccine coverage, a policy of mandatory vaccines has been applied since January 2019. As vaccine hesitancy has been described among healthcare workers, we aimed to assess the adhesion to vaccination in students enrolled in the first common year of healthcare studies (PACES), and their perceptions regarding the mandatory vaccine policy. METHODS: We elaborated an anonymous online questionnaire and asked the 35 French universities offering PACES studies to diffuse it to their students; 26 accepted. RESULTS: Overall, 4326 participants completed the questionnaire (age 18.7 ± 1.5 years, female 76.1%). They evaluated vaccine usefulness and harmfulness at a median of 90 [IQT:80-100] and 25 [IQT:10-50], respectively; on the same scale, their median trust in vaccines was 82 [IQT:70-94]. Among the five main age classes (17 to 21 years), the positive perceptions of vaccination declined with age. A majority declared that making vaccines mandatory was morally and scientifically justified (65.7% and 84.7%, respectively); in response to the questionnaire showing a blatant anti-mandatory vaccine billboard, 52.3% and 28.6%, respectively, strongly disagreed or rather disagreed with it. Again, these proportions declined between 17 and 21 years. Participants were asked whether the mandatory vaccine policy would improve their perceptions of vaccination; those with poorer perceptions were less likely to answer this question positively. CONCLUSION: The perceptions of vaccination and the recent mandatory vaccine policy are positive in first-year students but better in younger ones, thus suggesting that vaccination should be taught early, during this study year. The mandatory vaccine policy may not improve the perceptions of those with a high level of vaccine hesitancy.
引用
- Daudel L, Mary J, Epaulard O, et al. Perception of mandatory infant vaccines and trust in vaccination among first-year healthcare students: An opportunity window for the training of future healthcare workers. Vaccine. 2019. PMID: 31708179. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2019.10.099
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。