文献速递免疫规划卫生政策与健康促进

将治理晴雨表应用于疫苗接种系统:巴基斯坦农村地区的经验教训

Applying a governance barometer to vaccine delivery systems: Lessons from a rural district of Pakistan.
PubMed 文献 · Vaccine · 2019-11-04

在巴基斯坦农村服务不足地区,应用平衡计分卡(BSC)评估政府疫苗接种系统,识别需支持的关键领域并基准改进。45项免疫指标覆盖8个领域,干预前综合评分51%(不满意),干预后升至82%(满意)。外展准备、EPI督导和可核实接种量改善最大。

要点

  • BSC含45项免疫指标,覆盖人力资源、疫苗供应等8个领域。
  • 干预前综合评分51%(不满意),干预后82%(满意)。
  • 外展准备(53个百分点,p=0.01)、EPI督导(52个百分点,p=0.01)和可核实接种量(46个百分点,p=0.02)改善最大。

核心结论

  • BSC有助于优先针对该地区卫生系统疫苗接种中关键未满足需求进行干预,尤其改善了外展准备、EPI督导和可核实接种量。

研究设计与样本

  • 在巴基斯坦农村服务不足地区应用平衡计分卡(BSC),通过桌面审查、政府咨询和现场测试制定,最终确定8个领域45项免疫指标。
  • 数据通过卫生设施评估、客户出口访谈和家庭疫苗接种评估收集,对每个领域计算综合评分并分为不满意、临界和满意三类。
  • 对排名最低的5个领域实施为期2年的卫生系统强化(HSS)干预,干预后评估追踪进展。

主要发现

  • 该地区干预前累计评分为51%(不满意),干预后提高至82%(满意)。
  • 干预前,4个领域评分为满意,4个领域为不满意;不满意的领域为:外展准备、记录与督导、可核实接种量、客户沟通。
  • 干预后,8个领域中有6个评分为满意,2个从不满意外移至临界。
  • 改善最大的百分点(pp)为:外展准备(53个百分点,p=0.01)、EPI督导(52个百分点,p=0.01)和可核实接种量(46个百分点,p=0.02)。
  • 未通过HSS干预的3个领域评分变化最小:冷链维护(6个百分点)、安全接种实践(12个百分点)和疫苗供应(11个百分点)。

关键数值与推荐

  • BSC涵盖8个领域:人力资源;疫苗供应;安全接种实践;冷链维护;外展准备;记录与督导;可核实接种量;客户沟通。
  • 每个领域计算综合评分,并分为不满意、临界和满意三类。
  • 对排名最低的5个领域实施为期2年的卫生系统强化(HSS)干预。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

INTRODUCTION: Weak vaccine delivery systems in countries off-track for routine immunization targets, need in-depth evidence on system level barriers to be critically resourced and monitored. We applied a Balanced Score Card (BSC) approach in a rural underserved district of Pakistan to (i) identify critical areas needing support in the government vaccine delivery system; and (ii) for benchmarking improvements in the vaccine delivery system. METHODOLOGY: BSC was developed drawing on desk review, government consultations and field testing. 45 immunization indicators were finalized across 8 domains: human resource; vaccine supply; safe vaccination practice; cold chain maintenance; outreach preparedness; records & supervision; verifiable vaccination volume; and client communication. Data were collected through health facility assessments, client exit interviews and household vaccination assessment. A composite score was calculated for each domain and banded into unsatisfactory, borderline and satisfactory categories. 5 lowest ranking domains were targeted for 2 years of health systems strengthening (HSS) interventions. Post-intervention assessment tracked progress. RESULTS: The district obtained a cumulative score of 51% (unsatisfactory) at pre-intervention and improved to 82% (satisfactory) at post-intervention. At pre-intervention, 4 domains scored satisfactory and 4 scored unsatisfactory. Unsatisfactory scores were received for: outreach preparedness; records & supervision; verifiable vaccination volume; and client communication. Post intervention 6 of 8 domains scored satisfactory and 2 moved from unsatisfactory to borderline. Highest percentage point (pp) improvements were seen in outreach preparedness (53 pp, p = 0.01), EPI supervision (52 pp, p = 0.01) and verified vaccination volume (46 pp, p = 0.02). 3 domains that were not intervened through HSS interventions had minimal change in scoring - cold chain maintenance (6 pp), safe vaccination practice (12 pp) and vaccine supply (11 pp). CONCLUSION: BSC served to prioritize interventions towards critical unmet needs for vaccine delivery in the district health system and particularly helped to improve outreach preparedness, EPI supervision and verified vaccination volume.

来源:Vaccine,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Zaidi S, Riaz A, Hussain SS, et al. Applying a governance barometer to vaccine delivery systems: Lessons from a rural district of Pakistan. Vaccine. 2019. PMID: 31699503. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2019.10.052

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。