Facebook广告档案中的疫苗相关广告
研究分析了Facebook广告档案中2018年12月13日和2019年2月22日检索的505条疫苗相关广告,其中309条纳入分析,含163条(53%)支持疫苗广告和145条(47%)反对疫苗广告。反对疫苗广告的购买者人均广告数中位数显著更高,且信息主题较统一,强调疫苗危害(55%);支持疫苗广告来自83个不同购买者,目标多样。
要点
- 反对疫苗广告购买者人均广告数中位数显著高于支持疫苗广告。
- 反对疫苗广告信息较统一,55%强调疫苗危害。
- 支持疫苗广告来自83个不同购买者,目标包括促进接种(49%)等。
核心结论
- 少数反对疫苗广告购买者利用Facebook广告触达目标受众。
- Facebook将所有疫苗相关内容视为「国家重要议题」,进一步政治化了疫苗。
- 实施全面披露政策也限制了哪些广告能成功在Facebook上运行。
- 提高透明度和限制错误信息不应是分开的目标。
- 公共卫生传播工作应考虑对Facebook用户疫苗态度和行为的潜在影响。
研究设计与样本
- 使用关键词「vaccine」于2018年12月13日和2019年2月22日检索Facebook广告档案。
- 导出505条广告数据,由标注团队按内容分为支持疫苗、反对疫苗、不相关。
- 对主要广告主题进行专题分析,并使用Mann-Whitney U检验比较广告表现指标。
主要发现
- 309条广告纳入分析,其中163条(53%)为支持疫苗广告,145条(47%)为反对疫苗广告。
- 尽管广告数量相似,反对疫苗广告的购买者人均广告数中位数显著更高。
- 首次购买者较少可能完成披露信息,并面临广告被移除的风险。
- 反对疫苗广告信息相对统一,强调疫苗危害的占55%。
- 支持疫苗广告来自83个不同购买者,目标包括促进接种(49%)、疫苗相关慈善(15%)和疫苗相关政策(14%)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: In 2018, Facebook introduced Ad Archive as a platform to improve transparency in advertisements related to politics and "issues of national importance." Vaccine-related Facebook advertising is publicly available for the first time. After measles outbreaks in the US brought renewed attention to the possible role of Facebook advertising in the spread of vaccine-related misinformation, Facebook announced steps to limit vaccine-related misinformation. This study serves as a baseline of advertising before new policies went into effect. METHODS: Using the keyword 'vaccine', we searched Ad Archive on December 13, 2018 and again on February 22, 2019. We exported data for 505 advertisements. A team of annotators sorted advertisements by content: pro-vaccine, anti-vaccine, not relevant. We also conducted a thematic analysis of major advertising themes. We ran Mann-Whitney U tests to compare ad performance metrics. RESULTS: 309 advertisements were included in analysis with 163 (53%) pro-vaccine advertisements and 145 (47%) anti-vaccine advertisements. Despite a similar number of advertisements, the median number of ads per buyer was significantly higher for anti-vaccine ads. First time buyers are less likely to complete disclosure information and risk ad removal. Thematically, anti-vaccine advertising messages are relatively uniform and emphasize vaccine harms (55%). In contrast, pro-vaccine advertisements come from a diverse set of buyers (83 unique) with varied goals including promoting vaccination (49%), vaccine related philanthropy (15%), and vaccine related policy (14%). CONCLUSIONS: A small set of anti-vaccine advertisement buyers have leveraged Facebook advertisements to reach targeted audiences. By deeming all vaccine-related content an issue of "national importance," Facebook has further the politicized vaccines. The implementation of a blanket disclosure policy also limits which ads can successfully run on Facebook. Improving transparency and limiting misinformation should not be separate goals. Public health communication efforts should consider the potential impact on Facebook users' vaccine attitudes and behaviors.
引用
- Jamison AM, Broniatowski DA, Dredze M, et al. Vaccine-related advertising in the Facebook Ad Archive. Vaccine. 2019. PMID: 31732327. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2019.10.066
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。