支持医护人员应对疫苗犹豫的对话式资源可及性范围综述
该范围综述评估了旨在帮助医护人员与疫苗犹豫者沟通的对话式干预措施在网上的可及性。通过检索欧洲疾控中心干预目录和谷歌搜索,共识别31项干预措施并评审29项,均为文本型指导材料。研究发现许多资源位于搜索结果第五至十页且标题不明确,部分需付费或无法直接访问,提示资源获取存在及时性和便利性问题。
要点
- 共识别31项对话式干预措施,评审29项,均为文本型指导材料。
- 资源常位于搜索结果第五至十页,标题不明确,部分需付费或无法直接访问。
核心结论
- 尽管已开发众多支持医护人员与疫苗犹豫者沟通的干预措施,但在及时便捷获取这些材料方面存在根本性问题。
- 建立中央存储库或网站链接这些干预措施,可能有助于提高医护人员对可用干预措施的理解并增加使用率。
研究设计与样本
- 范围综述,通过评估欧洲疾控中心干预目录和进行仅限英语的谷歌搜索来识别对话式干预措施。
- 对话式干预措施定义为旨在提高个体与疫苗犹豫者接触和回应时的信心与沟通技能的策略。
主要发现
- 共识别31项对话式干预措施,其中29项被评审,所有干预措施均为文本型且具有指导性质。
- 许多资源常见于搜索结果的第五至十页,且通常隐藏在看似非描述性和非特异性的标题下。
- 并非所有资源均可免费获取,也并非所有资源均可直接从网站访问。
关键数值与推荐
- 对话式干预措施定义为旨在提高个体与疫苗犹豫者接触和回应时的信心与沟通技能的策略。
- 共识别31项对话式干预措施,其中29项被评审。
临床怎么用
- 医护人员在寻找支持疫苗沟通的对话式资源时,可能面临资源难以在搜索结果中及时定位的问题。
- 建议关注建立中央存储库或网站以链接可用干预措施,从而改善资源获取和理解。
局限性
- 仅使用英语进行谷歌搜索,可能遗漏非英语资源。
- 未报告对干预措施效果的评价,仅关注可及性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: There is growing attention around the need to improve the confidence and skills of healthcare providers to assist them in completing the complex task of communicating to vaccine hesitant parents and other individuals. While interventions have been developed and evaluated in a research setting, there is uncertainty regarding the public availability. This study aimed to examine the current landscape regarding the availability of online dialogue- based interventions which aim to support vaccination conversations. METHODS: A scoping review was undertaken to identify and appraise the availability and accessibility of dialogue-based interventions. A dialogue-based intervention was defined as a strategy aiming to improve an individual's confidence and communication skills to engage with and respond to vaccine hesitant individuals. Two approaches were utilised to identify relevant interventions and resources. Firstly, the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control Catalogue of Interventions was assessed to identify interventions that met the definition. Secondarily, a Google search (in English only) was conducted using key words, that reflected the strategy that healthcare providers may use to identify resources. RESULTS: We identified a total of 31 dialogue-based interventions, of which 29 were reviewed. The interventions were all text based and instructional in nature. Twenty-two were suitable for healthcare providers, as well as non-clinical immunisation spokespersons to use. Of issue, was that in many instances it was common to find the resource located on the fifth to tenth page of search entries, and usually disguised under seemingly non-descript and nonspecific titles. Lastly, not all resources were available for free and not all could be accessed directly from the site. CONCLUSIONS: Findings suggest that while there have been numerous interventions developed to support healthcare providers to communicate with vaccine hesitant parents/individuals, there are fundamental issues with accessing the materials in a timely and convenient way. Having a central repository or website (which links to the interventions) would not only assistant healthcare providers to have an improved comprehension of the different interventions available but also would theoretically increase the utilisation by providers.
引用
- Karras J, Dubé E, Danchin M, et al. A scoping review examining the availability of dialogue-based resources to support healthcare providers engagement with vaccine hesitant individuals. Vaccine. 2019. PMID: 31540811. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2019.09.039
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。