支持并维持集中式免疫提醒/召回:利益相关者的定性洞察
该研究采用定性内容分析,访谈州免疫信息系统、健康计划、卫生系统、制药公司和倡导组织的关键利益相关者,探讨集中式提醒/召回(C-R/R)的实施特征及影响其成功与维持的因素。结果显示决策、利益相关者认同、合作伙伴关系、资金、数据与技术、评估和消息内容是关键考量,成本与资金缺乏、联系数据质量差及消息过宽或过窄是主要障碍。
要点
- C-R/R成功需关注决策、认同、合作、资金、数据技术、评估和消息内容。
- 主要障碍包括成本与资金缺乏、联系数据质量差、消息过宽或过窄。
- 促进因素包括提前通知提供者、严格评估和多方合作。
核心结论
- 通过公共卫生部门内外合作及公私合作可推进C-R/R。
研究设计与样本
- 采用定性内容分析,访谈免疫信息系统、健康计划、卫生系统、制药公司和倡导组织的管理者与高级领导者。
主要发现
- C-R/R成功的重要考量包括决策、利益相关者认同、合作伙伴关系、资金、数据与技术、评估和消息内容。
- 显著障碍为成本与资金缺乏、联系数据质量差(电话、家庭地址)以及消息过宽或过窄。
- 促进因素包括提前通知卫生提供者、开展严格的提醒/召回后评估以及动员多方合作伙伴。
- 合作伙伴关系对利益相关者重要,原因包括技术援助、资源共享和最佳实践分享。
临床怎么用
- 在实施C-R/R前提前通知卫生提供者。
- 开展严格的提醒/召回后评估。
- 动员多方合作伙伴以获取技术援助、资源共享和最佳实践。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Centralized reminder/recall (C-R/R) is an evidence-based strategy for increasing vaccination rates that uses a population-level database such as a state immunization information system (IIS) to send notifications across large geographic areas. IISs are usually based in state public health departments, which could initiate C-R/R. While C-R/R is a promising strategy, the factors influencing its initiation and sustainment are not clear. Utilizing qualitative content analysis methodology and interviews with key stakeholders involved in or knowledgeable about C-R/R, we examined the characteristics of these initiatives and factors influencing their success. We identified and spoke with managers and senior leaders across IISs, health plans, health systems, pharmaceutical companies, and advocacy organizations and focused especially on C-R/R activities within IISs. Several considerations were determined important to C-R/R success: decision-making, stakeholder buy-in, partnerships, funding, data and technology, evaluation, and message content. Salient barriers were costs and lack of funding, poor contact data quality (i.e. telephone number, home address), and messaging that is either overly broad or too specific. Pertinent facilitators of C-R/R included notifying health providers in advance of an initiative, conducting a rigorous post-reminder/recall evaluation, and engaging a range of partners. Partnerships were important to stakeholders for multiple reasons including technical assistance, resource sharing, and sharing of best practices. Overall, our results illustrate the many opportunities to advance C-R/R through further collaboration within and across public health departments and potentially via public-private partnerships.
引用
- Fisher MP, Gurfinkel D, Szilagyi PG, et al. Supporting and sustaining centralized reminder/recall for immunizations: Qualitative insights from stakeholders. Vaccine. 2019. PMID: 31562003. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2019.09.055
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。