流感疫苗接种最佳时机的建模:免疫消退与疫苗覆盖率的影响
该建模研究基于系统综述的免疫消退函数及2007–2016年(排除2009年)年龄别通报数据和疫苗效果与覆盖率估计,模拟将接种从3月推迟至8月各月份对预防病例比例的影响。结果显示推迟接种至5月底可预防更多病例,但各月份差异不大;若推迟导致覆盖率下降,则净效应可能为负。推荐与接种之间的时间间隔使更早推荐更有效,结果对季节内免疫消退假设敏感。
要点
- 推迟接种至5月底较3月可预防更多病例,但各月份差异不大。
- 若推迟接种导致覆盖率下降,净效应可能为负。
- 考虑推荐与接种时间间隔时,更早推荐更有效。
核心结论
- 推迟流感疫苗接种至5月底可预防更多病例,但各月份差异不大;若推迟导致覆盖率下降则净效应可能为负。
- 考虑推荐与接种的时间间隔时,更早推荐更有效;结果对季节内免疫消退假设敏感。
研究设计与样本
- 基于系统综述计算接种后免疫消退函数,使用2007–2016年(排除2009年)年龄别通报数据及疫苗效果与覆盖率估计进行建模。
- 模拟将疫苗效果按接种月份从3月至8月推迟,生成新的通报序列,并对覆盖率变化及推荐与接种时间间隔进行敏感性分析。
主要发现
- 将接种从3月推迟至5月底可预防更多病例,但各月份预防病例数的变化不大。
- 若推迟接种导致遗漏或忘记接种并使覆盖率下降,推迟接种可能产生净负面效应。
- 考虑推荐与接种之间的时间间隔时,更早推荐在预防病例上更有效。
- 结果对季节内疫苗效果消退的假设敏感。
临床怎么用
- 在制定流感疫苗接种时间建议时,需权衡推迟接种可能带来的病例预防收益与覆盖率下降风险。
- 应重视推荐与接种之间的时间间隔,尽早推荐可能更有效。
局限性
- 结果对季节内疫苗效果消退的假设敏感。
- 需进一步研究季节内疫苗效果消退及推迟接种对总体接种率的影响,以指导现行接种建议的调整。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The influenza season in Australia usually peaks in August. Vaccination is recommended beginning in March-April. Recent studies suggest that vaccine effectiveness may wane over a given influenza season, leading to reduced effectiveness at the peak of the season. We aimed to quantify how changes in timing of influenza vaccination and declining vaccine coverage could change the percentages of prevented cases. Results from a systematic review were used to inform calculation of a waning function over time from vaccination. Age specific notification data and vaccine effectiveness and coverage estimates from 2007 to 2016 (2009 influenza pandemic year excluded) were used to model a new notification series where vaccine effectiveness is shifted in time to account for delayed vaccination by month from March to August. A sensitivity analysis was done on possible vaccine coverage changes and considering time gap between vaccine uptake and recommendation. Delaying vaccination from March to end of May prevents more cases over a season, but the variation in cases prevented by month of vaccination is not large. If delaying vaccination results in missed or forgotten vaccination and decrease coverage, delaying vaccination could have a net negative impact. Furthermore, considering a time gap between recommendation and uptake, earlier recommendation is more effective in preventing cases. The results are sensitive to assumptions of intra-seasonal waning of effectiveness. More research is required on intra-seasonal vaccine effectiveness waning and the effect of delayed vaccination on overall uptake to inform any potential changes to current vaccine scheduling recommendations.
引用
- Costantino V, Trent M, MacIntyre CR, et al. Modelling of optimal timing for influenza vaccination as a function of intraseasonal waning of immunity and vaccine coverage. Vaccine. 2019. PMID: 31521411. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2019.08.069
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。