文献速递免疫规划卫生政策与健康促进

儿童疫苗接种知情决策的影响因素:接受者、拒绝者与部分接受者的比较

A deliberate choice? Exploring factors related to informed decision-making about childhood vaccination among acceptors, refusers, and partial acceptors.
PubMed 文献 · Vaccine · 2019-08-02

本研究基于荷兰12个半结构化焦点小组访谈,分别纳入完全接受者、拒绝者和部分接受者,探讨儿童疫苗接种知情决策相关因素。结果显示接受者视接种为理所当然,拒绝者多依赖轶事信息权衡利弊,部分接受者对每种疫苗和疾病逐一详细斟酌,耗时且困难。研究建议加强儿童疫苗提供者与父母之间的深入对话以支持决策。

要点

  • 接受者视接种国家免疫规划为理所当然,较少深入权衡。
  • 拒绝者多依赖轶事信息而非循证信息权衡疫苗与疾病利弊。
  • 部分接受者逐一详细斟酌每种疫苗和疾病,耗时且困难。

核心结论

  • 接受者、拒绝者和部分接受者在儿童疫苗接种决策相关因素上存在明显差异。
  • 接受者视接种为理所当然,拒绝者多依赖轶事信息,部分接受者对每种疫苗逐一详细斟酌。

研究设计与样本

  • 在荷兰开展12个半结构化焦点小组访谈,基于知情决策定义设计访谈内容。
  • 访谈对象包括3组完全接受者、3组拒绝者和6组部分接受者,询问知识、态度、斟酌和信息需求,并对转录稿进行主题分析。

主要发现

  • 接受者视参与国家免疫规划的决定为理所当然。
  • 拒绝者和部分接受者报告对接受或拒绝国家免疫规划的利弊进行了非常详细的斟酌。
  • 拒绝者和部分接受者的知识并非总是循证的。
  • 拒绝者和部分接受者相比接受者感知疫苗可预防疾病风险更少、疫苗副作用风险更多、环境社会支持更少、对儿童福利中心和所提供信息的信任更低。

临床怎么用

  • 儿童疫苗提供者应与父母开展更深入的对话以支持和强化决策。
  • 对话可用于建立父母与疫苗提供者之间的信任、讨论儿童疫苗接种的循证优势,并降低父母对轶事信息和误区的易感性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: In light of the decline in childhood vaccination coverage, the question rises concerning what factors play a role in informed decision-making about childhood vaccination. Insight into factors related to this decision helps us to support parents' informed decision-making about childhood vaccination. METHOD: We conducted 12 semi-structured focus group interviews across the Netherlands based on a definition of informed decision-making: three with acceptors, three with refusers, and six with partial acceptors to ask about knowledge, attitudes, deliberation, and information needs. We performed a thematic analysis of the transcripts. RESULTS: Acceptors viewed the decision to participate in the National Immunization Program (NIP) as self-evident. Refusers and partial acceptors, however, reported to extensively deliberate the pros and cons of accepting or refusing the NIP in much detail. Their answers indicated that their knowledge was not always evidence-based. In addition, refusers and partial acceptors perceived fewer risks of vaccine-preventable diseases (VPDs), more risks of side-effects of vaccines, less social support from their environment, less trust in child welfare centers (CWCs), and information provided than acceptors. CONCLUSION: We observed distinct differences in factors related to decision-making about childhood vaccination between acceptors, refusers, and partial acceptors. Acceptors in the current study perceived accepting childhood vaccinations as self-evident, refusers relied mostly on anecdotal information rather than evidence-based information to weigh up the pros and cons vaccines and the VPDs, and partial acceptors elaborately deliberated the pros and cons of each vaccine and VPD individually, which was time-consuming and difficult. To strengthen and support decision-making among parents, more elaborate dialogues are needed between Child Vaccine Providers (CVPs) and parents. These discussions could build trust between parents and CVPs, be used to discuss the evidence-based advantages of childhood vaccinations, and to decrease parents' susceptibility to anecdotal information and misperceptions about childhood vaccinations shared by other parents.

来源:Vaccine,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Romijnders KAGJ, van Seventer SL, Scheltema M, et al. A deliberate choice? Exploring factors related to informed decision-making about childhood vaccination among acceptors, refusers, and partial acceptors. Vaccine. 2019. PMID: 31383488. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2019.07.060

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。