支持接种的澳大利亚人对疫苗拒斥运动的认知:一项主题话语分析
研究分析2666名支持接种的澳大利亚人对疫苗拒斥运动的描述,发现其认知普遍负面且带污名化,认为该运动危险、误导、由骗子和愚人组成。话语分析显示这些认知源于认为相信反疫苗言论者必有缺陷,以及该运动传播危险观念、攻击社会秩序。作者担忧污名化可能损害拒斥者福祉并固化其负面疫苗信念,呼吁更富同情心的公共讨论。
要点
- 支持接种者对疫苗拒斥运动持强烈负面和污名化认知。
- 这些认知源于难以想象有人会拒斥疫苗,认为其必有缺陷。
- 污名化可能损害拒斥者福祉并固化其负面疫苗信念。
核心结论
- 支持接种的澳大利亚人对疫苗拒斥运动持有负面且污名化的认知,可能损害拒斥者福祉并固化其负面疫苗信念。
- 研究呼吁在公共领域对疫苗拒斥进行更富同情心、更细致的讨论。
- 研究支持将公众对疫苗拒斥的态度作为疫苗信心的决定因素进行系统考察。
研究设计与样本
- 对2666名支持接种的澳大利亚人关于疫苗拒斥运动的描述进行主题话语分析。
- 采用归纳、迭代编码识别描述性主题,再运用话语分析技术解读潜在信念。
主要发现
- 参与者对疫苗拒斥运动持负面和污名化认知,认为其危险、被误导、由骗子和愚人组成。
- 参与者认为拒斥者不聪明、自私、过度情绪化、阴谋论且科学文盲。
- 话语分析显示这些认知源于认为相信反疫苗言论者必有缺陷,以及该运动传播危险观念、攻击社会秩序、制度、价值观和理性。
- 参与者的强烈负面看法与其无法想象有人会拒斥疫苗有关。
临床怎么用
- 公共卫生沟通应避免对疫苗拒斥者污名化,采用更富同情心、细致的讨论方式。
- 应将公众对疫苗拒斥的态度作为疫苗信心的决定因素进行系统考察。
局限性
- 研究为定性主题话语分析,结果反映支持接种的澳大利亚人的认知,外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Vaccine refusal is shaped by the social ecology in which it occurs. How people who refuse vaccines are communicated to and treated may affect the nature and strength of their negative vaccine beliefs, and their responsiveness to health promotion messages. Yet little is known about how people who refuse vaccines are perceived by the public. Our research examined perceptions among pro-vaccine Australians of the vaccine-refusal movement. METHODS: Descriptions of the vaccine-refusal movement by 2666 pro-vaccine Australians were analysed using thematic discourse analysis. Descriptive themes were identified via inductive, iterative coding. Discourse analysis techniques were then used to interpret latent beliefs about the vaccine-refusal movement. RESULTS: Participants had negative and stigmatising perceptions of the vaccine-refusal movement. They believed the movement is dangerous, misinformed, and comprised of charlatans and fools who are unintelligent, selfish, overly emotional, conspiratorial and scientifically illiterate. Discursive analysis showed that these perceptions were underpinned by beliefs that people would have to be defective in some way to believe anti-vaccine rhetoric. Furthermore, perceptions were underpinned by beliefs that the movement spreads not only disease, but also dangerous ideas that were seen to attack the social order, institutions, values and reason. Participants' intensely-negative views related to their inability to imagine why someone would refuse vaccines. CONCLUSIONS: This research provides a focused, qualitative account of public perceptions of the vaccine-refusal movement. The findings are concerning: stigma towards vaccine-refusing people may adversely affect their wellbeing and entrench their negative vaccine beliefs. The research suggests that more compassionate, nuanced discussion of vaccine refusal in the public sphere is needed. It also supports the need to systematically examine public attitudes towards vaccine refusal as a determinant of vaccine confidence.
引用
- Rozbroj T, Lyons A, Lucke J, et al. The mad leading the blind: Perceptions of the vaccine-refusal movement among Australians who support vaccination. Vaccine. 2019. PMID: 31451326. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2019.08.023
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。