免疫层析法与逆转录聚合酶链反应评估轮状病毒疫苗有效性的比较
该研究在日本静冈县一次轮状病毒暴发中,采用检测阴性设计比较免疫层析法(IC)与逆转录聚合酶链反应(RT-PCR)评估轮状病毒疫苗有效性(VE)。IC特异性为100%,敏感性为67%,低于RT-PCR(最高88%)。IC评估的VE为79%(95%CI: 39-93%),RT-PCR为58%(95%CI: -20% to 90%);在疾病严重程度较高时两者接近。接种疫苗儿童被IC检测出的几率降低80%[OR=0.192(95%CI: 0.052-0.709)]。
要点
- IC特异性100%,敏感性67%,低于RT-PCR的88%。
- IC评估VE为79%(95%CI: 39-93%),RT-PCR为58%(95%CI: -20% to 90%)。
- 重症病例中IC与RT-PCR评估的VE相近,IC可用于重症VE监测。
核心结论
- IC敏感性低于RT-PCR,但IC评估的VE在重症病例中与RT-PCR相近,可用于VE监测。
研究设计与样本
- 在日本静冈县一次暴发中,采用检测阴性设计,比较IC与RT-PCR评估轮状病毒疫苗有效性。
主要发现
- IC特异性为100%,敏感性为67%;RT-PCR敏感性随疾病严重程度升高至88%。
- IC评估VE为79%(95%CI: 39-93%),RT-PCR为58%(95%CI: -20% to 90%)。
- 疾病严重程度≥7时,IC评估VE为81.5%(95%CI: 40-94%),RT-PCR为72%(95%CI: 7-92%)。
- 疾病严重程度≥11时,IC评估VE为97.5%(95%CI: 77-99.7%),RT-PCR为92%(95%CI: 58-98%)。
- 接种疫苗儿童被IC检测出的几率降低80%[OR=0.192(95%CI: 0.052-0.709)]。
临床怎么用
- 在重症病例中,IC评估的VE与RT-PCR相近,可用于疫苗有效性监测。
局限性
- IC的敏感性和特异性因品牌类型而异,一般不如RT-PCR敏感。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Because of the large animal reservoirs and reassortment capacity of rotaviruses (RVs) that pose the possibilities of waning the effectiveness of RV-vaccines, it remains essential to monitor vaccine effectiveness (VE) regularly. Although reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) remains sensitive for RV detection, physicians, especially in Japan, frequently use immunochromatography (IC)-based kits for RV diagnosis. Recently, IC is being used to calculate VE also. Herein, we investigated the validity of VEs determined by IC compared to that by RT-PCR during an outbreak in Shizuoka Prefecture, Japan. METHODS: RVs in the stool or rectal swabs from children with acute gastroenteritis (AGE) were tested first by IC in the clinic and then by RT-PCR in the laboratory. A test-negative study design was used to examine VE. RESULTS: Although the specificity of IC assay revealed 100%, its sensitivity remained weaker (67%) than that of RT-PCR that increased up to 88% depending on disease severity. VE assessed by IC remained stronger than that by RT-PCR: 79% (95% CI: 39-93%) by IC, and 58% (95% CI: -20% to 90%) by RT-PCR. However, VEs by IC and RT-PCR appeared almost similar in higher disease severity: 81.5% (95% CI: 40-94%) by IC and 72% (95% CI: 7-92%) by RT-PCR at severity ≥7, while 97.5% (95% CI: 77-99.7%) by IC and 92% (95% CI: 58-98%) by RT-PCR at severity ≥11. We showed that RV-vaccinated children had 80% [OR = 0.192 (95% CI: 0.052-0.709) less chance to be detected by IC. CONCLUSION: Although the sensitivity and specificity of IC differ by brand type, generally, IC is not as sensitive as RT-PCR. Despite the VEs remain higher by IC, it looks comparable with that of RT-PCR in severe cases implying that VEs evaluated by IC against severe illness remain useful for VE-monitoring.
引用
- Hoque SA, Iizuka I, Kobayashi M, et al. Determining effectiveness of rotavirus vaccine by immunochromatography and reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction: A comparison. Vaccine. 2019. PMID: 31451325. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2019.07.091
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。