文献速递免疫规划传染病防控与疫情报告

基于检测阴性病例对照设计评价6~72月龄儿童流感疫苗效果

[Evaluation of the influenza vaccine effectiveness among children aged 6 to 72 months based on the test-negative case control study design].
PubMed 文献 · Zhonghua Yu Fang Yi Xue Za Zhi · 2019-01-01

两季合并流感疫苗效果为58%(95%CI:31%~74%),36~72月龄组为68%(95%CI:41%~82%),6~35月龄组为28%(95%CI:-80%~71%)。

要点

  • 两季合并6~72月龄儿童流感疫苗效果为58%(95%CI:31%~74%)。
  • 36~72月龄组疫苗效果68%(95%CI:41%~82%),高于6~35月龄组的28%(95%CI:-80%~71%)。
  • 2016—2017季疫苗效果54%(95%CI:16%~75%),对A(H3N2)为65%(95%CI:24%~83%)。

核心结论

  • 流感流行季节内流感疫苗对6~72月龄儿童有一定保护效果,36~72月龄组保护效果高于6~35月龄组。

研究设计与样本

  • 采用基于实验室检测结果的检测阴性病例对照研究设计,数据来自中国流感监测信息系统。
  • 采用倾向评分法均衡非随机化对照的混杂效应,多因素logistic回归模型计算疫苗效果及95%CI。

主要发现

  • 研究对象年龄为(2.44±1.60)岁,男童681例(58.66%);病例组年龄(2.62±1.58)岁,男童246例(61.04%);对照组年龄(2.35±1.61)岁,男童435例(57.39%)。
  • 病例组中A(H3N2)237例(58.81%)、甲型H1N1 92例(22.83%)、B(Victoria)系62例(15.38%)、B(Yamagata)系11例(2.73%)、混合感染1例(0.25%)。
  • 两季合并流感疫苗效果为58%(95%CI:31%~74%);36~72月龄组为68%(95%CI:41%~82%),6~35月龄组为28%(95%CI:-80%~71%)。
  • 2016—2017季流感疫苗效果为54%(95%CI:16%~75%),对A(H3N2)亚型为65%(95%CI:24%~83%)。
  • 2017—2018季流感疫苗效果为69%(95%CI:18%~88%)。

临床怎么用

  • 在流感流行季节前,可依据年龄分层向6~72月龄儿童家长说明流感疫苗的保护效果,36~72月龄组效果数据更为明确。
  • 对6~35月龄儿童,疫苗效果估计置信区间较宽,解读时应结合当地流行株与接种史综合判断。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Objective: To assess the effectiveness of seasonal influenza vaccine among children aged 6 to 72 months. Methods: The test-negative case control study was conducted based on available surveillance data which was from China Influenza Surveillance Information system (CSIS). From October 2016 to April 2017 and from October 2017 to April 2018,1 161 cases aged 6-72 months with influenza-like illness in Yongkang and Yiwu city, were selected as the study subjects, and the cases with influenza test-positive were selected as the case group (403 cases). Test-negative subjects were selected as control group (758 cases). The etiology and immunization data of the subjects were obtained from CSIS and Immune Information and Management System (IIMS) respectively. Vaccine effectiveness was estimated using multivariate logistic regression model,and the mixed effects of non-randomized control in TNCC study were equalized by using the propensity score (PS) method in the statistical analysis. Results: The age of the subjects was (2.44±1.60) years,and there were 681 boys (58.66%). The age of case group was (2.62±1.58) years, and there were 246 boys (61.04%). The case group was including of 237 cases (58.81%) of influenza A (H3N2), 92 cases (22.83%) of influenza A (H1N1) pmd09, 62 cases (15.38%) of influenza B(Victoria) lineage, 11 cases (2.73%) of influenza B (Yamagata) lineage and one case (0.25%) co-infection of influenza [A(H(3)N(2))+B (Victoria)]. The mean age of the control group was (2.35±1.61) years,and there were 435 boys (57.39%). Overall vaccine effectiveness (VE) against all type influenza for two seasons combined was 58% (95%CI: 31%-74%). An analysis by age groups showed 68% (95%CI:41%-82%) of the VE estimate among children aged 36-72 months while it was 28%(95%CI:-80%-71%)of the VE estimate among children aged 6-35 months. The VE estimate value was 54% (95%CI:16%-75%) against all type influenza and 65% (95%CI:24%-83%) against influenza A (H(3)N(2)) during the 2016-2017 season. During the 2017-2018 season, the VE estimate value was 69% (95%CI:18%-88%) against all type influenza. Conclusion: Influenza vaccine is effective in preventing influenza virus infection during the flu season,especially the effect among children aged 36-72 months is higher compared to that among children aged 6-35 months. 目的: 评价6~72月龄儿童流感苗的疫苗效果。 方法: 采用基于实验室检测结果病例-对照研究(TNCC)设计,从中国流感监测信息系统中,选取2016年10月至2017年4月及2017年10月至2018年4月永康和义乌市6~72月龄流感样病例(ILI)为研究对象,共1 161例,将流感病毒阳性者作为病例组(403例),阴性者作为对照组(758例)。从中国流感监测信息系统和免疫规划信息管理系统中获取研究对象的病原学和免疫接种资料,采用倾向评分(PS)法均衡TNCC研究中非随机化对照的混杂效应,采用多因素logistic回归模型,计算流感疫苗效果及其95%CI值。 结果: 研究对象的年龄为(2.44±1.60)岁,男童为681例(58.66%)。病例组年龄为(2.62±1.58)岁,A(H3N2)亚型、甲型H1N1、B(Victoria)系、B(Yamagata)系和混合型感染分别为237例(58.81%)、92例(22.83%)、62例(15.38%)、11例(2.73%)和1例(0.25%);男童为246例(61.04%)。对照组年龄为(2.35±1.61)岁,男童为435例(57.39%)。2个流感流行季内,流感疫苗效果(95%CI)为58%(31%~74%),36~72月龄组流感疫苗效果(95%CI)为68%(41%~82%),而6~35月龄为28%(-80%~71%)。2016—2017年流行季,流感疫苗效果(95%CI)为54%(16%~75%),对A(H3N2)亚型流感疫苗效果(95%CI)为65%(24%~83%)。2017—2018年流行季,流感疫苗效果(95%CI)为69%(18%~88%)。 结论: 流感流行季节内,流感疫苗效果较好,对6~72月龄儿童有一定保护效果,但对36~72月龄儿童保护效果高于6~35月龄儿童。.

来源:Zhonghua Yu Fang Yi Xue Za Zhi,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Luo SY, Zhu JL, Lyu MZ, et al. [Evaluation of the influenza vaccine effectiveness among children aged 6 to 72 months based on the test-negative case control study design]. Zhonghua Yu Fang Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2019. PMID: 31177753. doi:10.3760/cma.j.issn.0253-9624.2019.06.007

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。