影响中国成人流感疫苗接种选择因素的相对效应及启动效应作用
研究将中国成人随机分配至对照或三种健康风险启动条件后开展离散选择实验,用混合logit模型估计影响接种选择的属性相对效应。结果显示疫苗效力效应大于社会线索,社会线索可补偿疫苗安全性不确定;流感病死率达20%时成为最重要属性;社区接种率从5%升至60%偏好增加,达80%后下降。
要点
- 疫苗效力对接种选择的影响大于社会线索,但社会线索可补偿疫苗安全性不确定。
- 流感病死率达20%时成为所有属性中最重要因素。
- 社区接种率5%升至60%偏好增加,80%后下降,干预风险启动下更明显。
核心结论
- 流感后果较轻时提升疫苗效力信心更重要,病死率升高时强调疾病后果愈发重要。
- 新疫苗安全性不确定时,医生和早期接种者参与验证疫苗安全性应重要。
- 短暂暴露于流感或疫苗风险未增加特定风险对接种选择的影响,但可能改变疾病与干预风险的相对权重。
- 社区接种率高时可能增加对群体免疫的搭便车行为,尤其在干预风险启动后。
研究设计与样本
- 中国成人被随机分配至对照条件(非风险相关视频)或三种健康风险启动条件之一(疾病风险视频、干预风险视频、非特异风险视频),每组约200名参与者,随后进行离散选择实验调查。
- 采用混合logit模型估计预定属性对接种选择的相对效应。
主要发现
- 在所有四种条件下,疫苗效力对接种选择的影响大于社会线索(社区疫苗接种覆盖率和医生建议),但社会线索可补偿「不确定」疫苗安全性的效应。
- 流感病死率达到20%时,在所有纳入属性中成为主导重要因素。
- 社区疫苗接种覆盖率从5%增量变化至60%时接种偏好增加,但此后达到80%时下降。
- 与对照参与者相比,社区疫苗接种覆盖率增加80%对干预风险启动参与者的接种选择影响较小。
- 疾病风险启动后,流感风险相对于疫苗风险的效应增加。
临床怎么用
- 流感后果较轻时,应重点提升公众对疫苗效力的信心。
- 流感病死率升高时,应加强强调疾病后果以促进接种。
- 新疫苗安全性不确定时,应让医生和早期接种者参与验证疫苗安全性。
- 社区接种率高时需注意搭便车行为,尤其在干预风险启动后。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To assess the relative effects of altering different factors (attributes) related to adults' decision for influenza vaccination choice, and whether priming modifies these relative effects. METHODS: Chinese adults were randomly allocated to either a control condition (non-risk related video), or one of the three health risk-priming conditions (disease (influenza) risk video, intervention (vaccine) risk video, or non-specific (air pollution) risk video), each comprising ∼200 participants, prior to a discrete choice experiment survey. Mixed logit modelling estimated the relative effects of pre-determined attributes influencing vaccination choice. RESULTS: Across all four conditions, for determining vaccination choice, Vaccine Efficacy had a greater effect than social cues (community vaccination coverage rate (CVCR) and doctors' advice) but social cues can compensate for the effect of "uncertain" vaccine safety; influenza case-fatality ratio (CFR) became dominantly important among all included attributes when it reached 20%; vaccination preference increased when a CVCR changed incrementally from 5% to 60% but declined thereafter when the CVCR reached 80%. Compared with Control participants, a CVCR increased by 80% had a smaller effect for participants primed by intervention risk on vaccination choice, while the effect of influenza risk relative to vaccine risk increased following disease risk priming. CONCLUSION: While increasing confidence on vaccine efficacy is more important for influenza with less severe consequences, highlighting disease consequences becomes increasingly important when its CFR increases, for promoting vaccination uptake. For a new vaccine with uncertain safety, involving doctors and early vaccine takers to validate vaccine safety should be important. Brief exposure to influenza/vaccine risk didn't increase the effect of specific risk on vaccination choice but may change the relative weight of disease versus intervention risk when individuals make trade-off for vaccination decision. Free riding on herd immunity may increase when community vaccination coverage is high particularly following intervention risk priming.
引用
- Liao Q, Lam WWT, Wong CKH, et al. The relative effects of determinants on Chinese adults' decision for influenza vaccination choice: What is the effect of priming? Vaccine. 2019. PMID: 31186189. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2019.05.072
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。