学生健康管理者视角下的高校疫苗政策制定与实施
本研究对美国十所高校的学生健康管理者进行半结构化访谈,探讨高校疫苗政策制定与实施的影响因素。管理者认可本校疫苗要求,但担忧哲学与宗教豁免的接受度,并依赖政府、专业组织和州法规决策。采购、储存和追踪疫苗的成本是主要障碍。
要点
- 学生健康管理者普遍认可本校疫苗要求,但部分担忧哲学与宗教豁免的接受度。
- 高校疫苗政策决策依赖政府、专业组织及州法规,合作与成本是实施的关键因素。
- 学生虽认可接种益处,但对疫苗要求态度中立且不优先考虑免疫接种。
核心结论
- 学生健康管理者积极看待本校疫苗要求,但部分对哲学和宗教豁免的接受度表示担忧。
- 学生普遍对疫苗要求态度中立,虽认可接种益处但不优先考虑免疫接种。
- 高校疫苗政策决策依赖政府、专业组织及州法规,合作是促进因素,成本是主要障碍。
研究设计与样本
- 定性研究,对来自十所美国高校的学生健康管理者(N=10)进行半结构化访谈,按学校类型和地理区域有目的抽样。
- 使用NVivo 11软件对访谈进行双编码,编码一致性κ=0.87,观察者间信度=99.4%。
主要发现
- 共编码5785个短语。
- 管理者积极看待本校疫苗要求,但部分对哲学和宗教豁免的接受度表示担忧。
- 学生普遍对疫苗要求态度中立,虽认可接种益处但不优先考虑免疫接种。
- 所有管理者均表示依赖政府、专业组织及州法规进行疫苗要求与推荐的决策。
- 与学校其他部门、制药公司、免疫联盟及医疗保健提供者的合作常被提及为促进因素,采购、储存和追踪疫苗的成本是主要障碍。
临床怎么用
- 高校疫苗政策制定可借鉴政府、专业组织及州法规,并加强跨部门与合作机构的伙伴关系。
- 需关注疫苗采购、储存和追踪成本这一主要实施障碍,优化资源配置。
- 针对学生对免疫接种不优先的态度,可开展健康教育提升疫苗接受度。
局限性
- 本研究为定性研究,样本量较小(N=10),可能限制结果的普遍性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Immunization policies at colleges and universities differ greatly for many reasons, including prior experience with disease outbreaks and state immunization requirements. Few studies comprehensively explore the range of factors that influence the development of college vaccine policies or facilitators and barriers to their implementation. OBJECTIVE: To explore the perceptions and decision-making process that influence college vaccine policy development and implementation from the perspective of student health administrators. METHODS: This qualitative study used semi-structured interviews with student health administrators (N = 10) from ten U.S. colleges and universities purposefully sampled by school type (public vs. private) and geographic region. A descriptive codebook was developed from the interview guide, and each interview was double-coded using NVivo 11 software (κ = 0.87; inter-observer reliability = 99.4%). RESULTS: We coded 5785 phrases. Administrators positively viewed their institutions' vaccine requirements, but some expressed concerns about the acceptance of philosophical and religious exemptions. They noted that students were generally ambivalent towards vaccine requirements, and while students recognized the benefits of vaccination, they did not prioritize immunizations. All administrators cited reliance on governmental and professional organizations as well as state regulations for decisions regarding vaccine requirements and recommendations at their institutions. Partnerships with other school departments, pharmaceutical companies, immunization coalitions, and healthcare providers were frequently cited as facilitators of college vaccine programs. Costs of purchasing, storing, and tracking vaccines were identified as major barriers. CONCLUSIONS: We identified key themes that can be evaluated in subsequent studies to identify factors associated with successful implementation of university immunization programs and inform initiatives to increase vaccine acceptance and optimize immunization rates on college and university campuses.
引用
- Fawole OA, Srivastava T, Feemster KA, et al. Student health administrator perspectives on college vaccine policy development and implementation. Vaccine. 2019. PMID: 31164307. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2019.05.073
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。