简短衰弱访谈与验证性衰弱指数在急性呼吸道疾病住院成人中的比较
本研究开发了5问题衰弱简短访谈,并在两个流感季节的多中心医院流感研究中,与基于病历回顾的59参数验证性衰弱指数进行比较。2070名急性呼吸道疾病住院成人中,简短访谈判定43%为衰弱,衰弱指数判定32%;两者仅中度相关且一致性低。衰弱指数升高与流感疫苗接种可能性增加相关,而简短访谈无此关联。
要点
- 5问题衰弱简短访谈在急性呼吸道疾病住院成人中可行且跨医院跨年度一致。
- 简短访谈与验证性衰弱指数仅中度相关、一致性低,提示衰弱概念存在差异。
- 衰弱指数升高与流感疫苗接种可能性增加相关,简短访谈则无此关联。
核心结论
- 简短衰弱访谈可行且一致,但与验证性衰弱指数仅中度相关,且与流感疫苗接种的关联不同,提示两种工具对衰弱的概念化存在差异。
研究设计与样本
- 研究开发了5问题衰弱简短访谈,并在为期两年的多中心医院流感研究中实施。
- 将简短访谈判定的衰弱状态与基于病历回顾59个参数的验证性衰弱指数进行比较。
- 纳入2015-2016和2016-2017流感季节2070名因急性呼吸道疾病住院的成人患者进行分析。
主要发现
- 研究人群中衰弱常见:43%的参与者被简短访谈定义为衰弱,32%被衰弱指数定义为衰弱。
- 简短访谈回答与衰弱指数仅中度相关,两种衰弱测量之间的一致性低。
- 女性比男性更可能被简短访谈定义为衰弱。
- 白种人比其他种族更可能被衰弱指数定义为衰弱。
- 衰弱指数升高与流感疫苗接种可能性增加相关,但简短访谈与疫苗接种无关联。
临床怎么用
- 在时间与资源有限的流感及流感疫苗研究中,可采用5问题衰弱简短访谈作为可行的衰弱测量工具。
- 需注意简短访谈与验证性衰弱指数判定结果不一致,解读衰弱与疫苗接种关联时应考虑测量工具差异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Frailty is an important physiologic factor in studies of influenza and influenza vaccines carried out in older adults and hospitalized populations. Unfortunately, comprehensive assessments of frailty requiring physical assessments and extensive medical record review are not often feasible in time- and resource-limited settings common to studies of influenza and influenza vaccines. METHODS: We developed a 5-question frailty short interview, and implemented it in a multicenter, hospital-based study of influenza over two years. Frailty status defined by the frailty short interview was compared to a validated frailty index based on medical record review of 59 parameters. Agreement between the two frailty measures was assessed, and multivariable linear regression models were used to explore differences between the measures. The association between each frailty measure and likelihood of influenza vaccination was also assessed. RESULTS: During the 2015-2016 and 2016-2017 influenza seasons, 2070 adult patients hospitalized with acute respiratory illness were enrolled and included in analyses. Frailty was frequently identified in the study population; 43% of participants were defined as frail by the frailty short interview and 32% by frailty index. Responses to the frailty short interview were only moderately correlated with the frailty index, and agreement between the two frailty measures was low. Women were more likely to be defined as frail by the frailty short interview than men. White individuals were more likely than other races to be defined as frail by the frailty index. Increasing frailty index was associated with increased likelihood of influenza vaccination, but the frailty short interview was not associated with vaccination. CONCLUSIONS: The frailty short interview provided a feasible and consistent measure of frailty across study hospitals and study years. However, its modest correlation with the frailty index and differential association with likelihood of influenza vaccination highlight differences in the conceptualization of frailty.
引用
- Petrie JG, Martin ET, Zhu Y, et al. Comparison of a frailty short interview to a validated frailty index in adults hospitalized for acute respiratory illness. Vaccine. 2019. PMID: 31113675. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2019.05.051
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。