贝宁、马拉维和格鲁吉亚私营部门免疫融资与提供的范围及规模
该研究在贝宁、马拉维和格鲁吉亚调查50家私营提供者并开展300余次客户 Exit 访谈,估计私营部门疫苗接种比例、私人支出及监管程度。三国私营模式不同,马拉维44%私营机构承担27%接种,贝宁18%机构承担8%,格鲁吉亚样本均为私营管理;私人支出占国家卫生支出不足1%,服务质量参差不齐。
要点
- 三国私营机构接种占比差异大:马拉维27%、贝宁8%,格鲁吉亚样本均为私营管理。
- 6-76%客户支付象征性费用,2-26%客户自费接种国家程序外疫苗。
- 私人疫苗接种支出占国家卫生支出不足1%。
核心结论
- 私营部门在低收入国家作用渐增并扩大服务可及性,政府应优先监管私营免疫服务并促进质量与可负担性。
研究设计与样本
- 在贝宁、马拉维和格鲁吉亚每国调查50家私营提供者的分层随机样本,使用标准化预测试问卷由培训调查员执行。
- 每国开展300次或以上客户 Exit 访谈。
主要发现
- 马拉维44%私营机构(主要为信仰组织)承担估计27%的全部接种。
- 贝宁18%私营营利和非营利机构提供接种,占全部接种的8%。
- 格鲁吉亚所有样本机构均为私营管理,承担100%的私营接种。
- 三国卫生部均向私营机构提供疫苗和其他支持。
- 6-76%客户支付接种卡和服务的象征性费用,2-26%客户选择支付更高费用接种国家程序外疫苗。
临床怎么用
- 政府应将监管和监督私营免疫服务、促进私营部门质量和可负担服务作为优先事项。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Little is known about the role of private sector providers in providing and financing immunization. To fill this gap, the authors conducted a study in Benin, Malawi, and Georgia to estimate (1) the proportion of vaccinations taking place through the private sector; (2) private expenditures for vaccination; and (3) the extent of regulation. METHODS: In each country, the authors surveyed a stratified random sample of 50 private providers (private for-profit and not-for-profit) using a standardized, pre-tested questionnaire administered by trained enumerators. In addition, the authors conducted 300 or more client exit interviews in each country. RESULTS: The three countries had different models of private service provision of vaccination. In Malawi, 44% of private facilities, predominantly faith-based organizations, administered an estimated 27% of all vaccinations. In Benin, 18% of private for-profit and not-for-profit facilities provided vaccinations, accounting for 8% of total vaccinations. In Georgia, all sample facilities were privately managed, and conducted 100% of private vaccinations. In all three countries, the Ministries of Health (MoHs) supplied vaccines and other support to private facilities. The study found that 6-76% of clients paid nominal fees for vaccination cards and services, and a small percentage (2-26%) chose to pay higher fees for vaccines not within their countries' national schedules. The percentage of private expenditure on vaccination was less than 1% of national health expenditures. The case studies revealed that service quality at private facilities was mixed, a finding that is similar to those of other studies on private sector vaccination. The three countries varied in how well the MoHs managed and supervised private sector services. DISCUSSION/CONCLUSION: The private sector plays a growing role in lower-income countries and is expanding access to services. Governments' ability to regulate and monitor immunization services and promote quality and affordable services in the private sector should be a priority.
引用
- Levin A, Munthali S, Vodungbo V, et al. Scope and magnitude of private sector financing and provision of immunization in Benin, Malawi and Georgia. Vaccine. 2019. PMID: 31122855. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2019.05.023
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。