心理干预作为疫苗佐剂的系统综述
该研究系统检索了EMBASE、Medline、PsychINFO、CINAHL等数据库至2018年2月6日,纳入9项试验共1603名参与者,评估心理干预对疫苗抗体应答的影响。结果显示6/9试验观察到抗体应答获益,但效果不一致,仅在3项试验中所有抗体结局和所有时间点均改善,且获益试验多提供干预依从性证据。结论认为早期证据提示心理干预可能增强疫苗抗体应答,但需更严谨设计和大型随机对照试验验证。
要点
- 心理干预可能增强疫苗抗体应答,但证据不一致。
- 获益试验多显示良好干预依从性,依从性可能是关键因素。
- 现有研究异质性大,需大型随机对照试验进一步验证。
核心结论
- 早期证据提示心理干预可能增强疫苗抗体应答,但效果不一致,干预依从性良好的试验更可能获益。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述检索EMBASE、Medline、PsychINFO、CINAHL数据库至2018年2月6日,纳入9项合格试验共1603名参与者。
主要发现
- 干预类型包括冥想/正念(n=3)、按摩(n=3)、表达性写作(n=2)和认知行为压力管理(n=1)。
- 6/9试验观察到疫苗抗体应答获益,随机对照试验中为4/7。
- 仅3/6显示获益的试验在所有抗体结局和所有时间点均改善。
- 获益试验提供干预依从性证据,其中50%试验显示干预改变了靶向的心理中介构念。
临床怎么用
- 心理干预可作为提升疫苗抗体应答的辅助策略,但需确保干预依从性。
- 目前证据尚不足以推荐常规使用,应结合个体情况谨慎考虑。
局限性
- 干预类型、疫苗类型、参与者年龄及干预与接种时间关系异质性大。
- 效果不一致,仅少数试验显示全面抗体改善。
- 需要更严谨的干预开发和大型随机对照试验。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The effectiveness of vaccines is known to be altered by a range of psychological factors. We conducted a systematic review to evaluate the effects of psychological interventions on the ability of vaccines to protect against disease, as measured by antibody responses. METHODS: Electronic databases (EMBASE, Medline, PsychINFO, CINAHL) were searched from their inception to 6th February 2018. RESULTS: The search yielded 9 eligible trials conducted with 1603 participants and four broad categories of intervention: meditation/mindfulness (n = 3), massage (n = 3), expressive writing (n = 2) and cognitive behavioural stress management (n = 1). Some evidence of benefit on the antibody response to vaccination was observed in 6/9 of all trials and in 4/7 of randomised controlled trials. However, effects on antibody levels were often mixed, with only 3 of 6 trials showing benefit demonstrating an improvement in all antibody outcomes and at all time points assessed. Trials demonstrating benefit also provided direct or indirect evidence of adequate adherence with the intervention; and in 50% of these trials, there was also evidence that the intervention was effective in changing the mediating psychological constructs targeted by the intervention. CONCLUSIONS: This literature is characterised by considerable heterogeneity in terms of intervention type, vaccine type, age of participants and the temporal relationship between vaccination and intervention. We conclude that there is early evidence to suggest that psychological interventions may enhance the antibody response to vaccination. However, the effects are inconsistent, with the greatest likelihood of benefit seen in trials evidencing adequate adherence with the intervention. Future work would benefit from rigorous intervention development that focuses on achieving adequate adherence and large well-controlled randomised trials with a focus on an agreed set of outcomes.
引用
- Vedhara K, Ayling K, Sunger K, et al. Psychological interventions as vaccine adjuvants: A systematic review. Vaccine. 2019. PMID: 31068258. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2019.04.091
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。