口服霍乱疫苗对马拉维奇尔瓦湖渔民预防霍乱的效果:病例对照研究
2016年马拉维奇尔瓦湖霍乱暴发期间,针对难以覆盖的流动渔民采用新型疫苗分发策略:首剂监督接种,第二剂密封袋交予渔民两周后自行服用。研究采用病例对照检测阴性设计和筛查法评估短期保护效果,结果显示三个月内渔民中疫苗有效性为90.0%[95%CI:38.8;98.4],筛查法为97.5%[95%CI:90.9;99.3]。
要点
- 渔民接种两剂口服霍乱疫苗后三个月保护效果达90.0%[95%CI:38.8;98.4]。
- 筛查法估计疫苗有效性为97.5%[95%CI:90.9;99.3]。
- 该策略对难以覆盖的流动渔民提供短期保护。
核心结论
- 该疫苗分发策略能为渔民提供短期霍乱保护。
研究设计与样本
- 病例对照检测阴性设计,比较PCR阳性病例与PCR阴性腹泻对照。
- 筛查法比较霍乱病例与一般渔民人群的接种比例。
- 共145名参与者,其中120名为湖上渔民。
主要发现
- 渔民中三个月疫苗有效性为90.0%[95%CI:38.8;98.4]。
- 所有参与者中疫苗有效性为83.3%[95%CI:20.8;96.5]。
- 筛查法估计疫苗有效性为97.5%[95%CI:90.9;99.3]。
临床怎么用
- 在难以覆盖的流动人群中可采用首剂监督、第二剂密封袋自行服用的分发策略。
局限性
- 需进一步研究确定第二剂的附加价值及不同情境下的最优接种策略。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: In response to a cholera outbreak among mobile, difficult-to-reach fishermen on Lake Chilwa, Malawi in 2016, a novel vaccine distribution strategy exploited the proven vaccine thermostability. Fishermen, while taking the first vaccine dose under supervision, received the second dose in a sealed bag, and were told to drink it two weeks later. This study assessed short-term vaccine protection of this strategy. METHODS: Patients with diarrhoea admitted to health facilities around lake were interviewed and a stool sample collected for PCR testing. Vaccine effectiveness was assessed in a case-control test-negative design by comparing cases (PCR-positive for V. cholerae O1) and controls (patients with diarrhoea but PCR-negative) and with the screening method that compared the proportions of vaccinated among cholera cases versus the general fishermen population. RESULTS: Of 145 study participants, 120 were fishermen living on the lake. Vaccine effectiveness at three-months was 90.0% [95%CI:38.8;98.4] among fishermen and 83.3% [95%CI: 20.8; 96.5] among all participants in the case-control test-negative design, and 97.5% [95%CI: 90.9;99.3] with the screening method. CONCLUSION: This strategy was effective in providing short-term protection in fishermen against cholera. Further research is needed to determine the adding value of the second dose and to identify the optimal vaccination strategies for different contexts.
引用
- Grandesso F, Kasambara W, Page AL, et al. Effectiveness of oral cholera vaccine in preventing cholera among fishermen in Lake Chilwa, Malawi: A case-control study. Vaccine. 2019. PMID: 31133470. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2019.05.044
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。