疫苗安全监测的情境性:丹麦2015年HPV疫苗接种后不良事件报告研究
该研究结合定量与定性方法,评估丹麦2015年「One Access」中心1577名HPV疫苗接种后疑似不良事件患者向丹麦药品管理局(DMA)报告的完整性,并访谈医生探讨报告行为。仅404人(26%)被报告,存在显著地区差异(p<0.001),报告行为受知识、动机与目标、环境背景等因素影响。
要点
- 1577名One Access患者中仅404人(26%)报告至DMA。
- 报告完整性存在显著地区差异(p<0.001)。
- 医生报告行为受知识、动机与目标、环境背景等因素影响。
核心结论
- 尽管官方目标是同质化病例管理,疑似AEFI报告不完整且存在较大地区差异。
- 定性研究证实报告行为具有情境性,这对解读AEFI报告数据构成重要警示。
研究设计与样本
- 研究包括定量和定性两部分。
- 定量分析通过丹麦民事登记号将2015年所有One Access转诊患者名单与2009-2015年向DMA报告HPV疫苗接种后疑似严重AEFI的患者总数进行链接。
- 定性部分对代表5个地区中3个地区的医生进行了四次半结构化访谈,以理论领域框架和两次临床实地考察的实证数据指导研究。
主要发现
- 1577名One Access患者中,仅404人(26%)报告至DMA。
- 报告完整性存在显著地区差异(p < 0.001)。
- 不同地区报告者背景(医疗专业人员 vs 非专业人员)存在差异(p = 0.004)。
- 识别出影响医生报告行为的多个重要因素,主要涉及知识、动机与目标、环境背景等领域。
临床怎么用
- 解读AEFI报告数据时需考虑报告行为的情境性,尤其在用于研究或政策制定时。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: In 2013-15, Denmark experienced an increase in reported suspected adverse events following vaccination (AEFI) against human papilloma virus (HPV). Dedicated centres ("One Access") were established in order to standardize management of patients who experienced medically unexplained physical symptoms after HPV vaccination. Since One Access was targeted patients with suspected AEFI after HPV vaccination, we used this opportunity to estimate completeness in AEFI reporting to the Danish Medicines Agency (DMA), and explore the topic of AEFI reporting from the perspective of physicians working at the centres to better understand health professionals' reporting behaviour. METHODS: The study consisted of a quantitative and a qualitative part. In the quantitative analysis, we used the Danish civil registry number to merge a line-list of all One Access patients referred in 2015 with total number of patients who had reported suspected serious AEFI following HPV vaccination to the DMA in the years 2009-2015. We conducted four semi-structured interviews with doctors representing three out of five regions. The Theoretical Domains Framework together with empirical data from two clinical fieldtrips guided the formation of the qualitative study. RESULTS: Among 1577 One Access patients, only 404 (26%) were reported to the DMA. We found significant regional differences in reporting completeness (p < 0.001) and differences between regions when looking at reporters' backgrounds (healthcare professionals vs non-professionals; p = 0.004). We identified several factors of importance for reporting behaviour amongst physicians, mainly under the domains of Knowledge, Motivation & Goals, and Environmental Context. CONCLUSIONS: Despite an official aim of homogenous case management, reporting of suspected AEFI was incomplete with large regional differences. The qualitative study corroborated that reporting behaviour was contextual. This observation represents an important caveat in interpreting data from AEFI reporting, in particular when these data are used for research or policymaking.
引用
- Schartau S, Heering Holt D, Lützen T, et al. On the contextual nature of vaccine safety monitoring: Adverse events reporting after HPV-vaccination in Denmark, 2015. Vaccine. 2019. PMID: 30967312. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2019.03.057
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。