乌干达START方法提升常规免疫规划人力能力
乌干达采用START方法,由外部顾问对50个区(占45%)的444家表现不佳卫生中心进行在职培训和导师指导,中位访问2次。观察到员工积极性和规划监测工具可用性改善,但改变持久性可能受外部问责、资源和员工态度限制。
要点
- START方法通过外部顾问现场带教提升区级和卫生中心常规免疫规划能力。
- 在444家卫生中心开展在职培训,中位访问2次,超半数访问与区免疫官员协作。
- 员工动机和工具可用性改善,但持久性受外部问责、资源和态度影响。
核心结论
- 导师指导与在职培训是替代传统课堂培训和审计式监督的有前景策略,但需进一步比较有效性和持久性证据。
研究设计与样本
- 在乌干达实施START方法,由外部顾问利用现有工具资源对区级和卫生中心人员进行在职培训和导师指导,通过每日活动报告、前后调查和访谈监测。
主要发现
- 在444家选定的表现不佳卫生中心进行在职培训,中位访问2次(范围1-7,IQR:1-3)。
- 超过一半的访问与区免疫官员协作,提供指导机会。
- 观察到员工动机、挑战意识以及常规免疫规划监测工具和系统的可用性与完成情况有变化。
临床怎么用
- 可考虑采用导师指导和在职培训作为传统课堂培训和审计式监督的替代或补充方法,以建设免疫规划人力能力。
局限性
- START顾问认为变化的潜在持久性可能受外部问责、资源可用性和员工个人态度等背景因素限制。
- 需要进一步证据比较这些策略的相对有效性和观察到的积极变化的持久性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: The Global Vaccine Action Plan identifies workforce capacity building as a key strategy to achieve strong immunization programs. The Strengthening Technical Assistance for Routine Immunization Training (START) approach aimed to utilize practical training methods to build capacity of district and health center staff to implement routine immunization (RI) planning and monitoring activities, as well as build supportive supervision skills of district staff. METHODS: First implemented in Uganda, the START approach was executed by trained external consultants who used existing tools, resources, and experiences to mentor district-level counterparts and, with them, conducted on-the-job training and mentorship of health center staff over several site visits. Implementation was routinely monitored using daily activity reports, pre and post surveys of resources and systems at districts and health centers and interviews with START consultants. RESULTS: From July 2013 through December 2014 three START teams of four consultants per team, worked 6 months each across 50 districts in Uganda including the five divisions of Kampala district (45% of all districts). They conducted on-the-job training in 444 selected under-performing health centers, with a median of two visits to each (range 1-7, IQR: 1-3). More than half of these visits were conducted in collaboration with the district immunization officer, providing the opportunity for mentorship of district immunization officers. Changes in staff motivation and awareness of challenges; availability and completion of RI planning and monitoring tools and systems were observed. However, the START consultants felt that potential durability of these changes may be limited by contextual factors, including external accountability, availability of resources, and individual staff attitude. CONCLUSIONS: Mentoring and on-the-job training offer promising alternatives to traditional classroom training and audit-focused supervision for building health workforce capacity. Further evidence regarding comparative effectiveness of these strategies and durability of observed positive change is needed.
引用
- Ward K, Stewart S, Wardle M, et al. Building health workforce capacity for planning and monitoring through the Strengthening Technical Assistance for routine immunization training (START) approach in Uganda. Vaccine. 2019. PMID: 31000410. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2019.04.015
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。