强制疫苗接种与无过错疫苗伤害补偿方案:国家层面政策识别
研究旨在识别同时实施儿童强制疫苗接种政策与无过错疫苗伤害补偿方案的国家。通过现有文献、列表和数据库及政策细节核实,共识别62个有儿童强制疫苗接种政策的国家,其中仅7个(11%)建立了无过错补偿方案。结论认为强制接种国家缺乏补偿方案可能被视为违背社会契约。
要点
- 62个有儿童强制疫苗接种政策的国家中仅7个(11%)有无过错补偿方案。
- 无过错补偿方案是应对疫苗接种罕见不良后果的政府手段之一。
- 强制接种却无补偿方案可能被视为违背社会契约,尤其当政策限制父母选择时。
核心结论
- 在识别出的62个实施儿童强制疫苗接种政策的国家中,仅7个(11%)同时建立了无过错疫苗伤害补偿方案。
- 强制疫苗接种国家缺乏无过错补偿方案可能被视为违背社会契约,尤其当公共政策限制父母接种选择时。
研究设计与样本
- 利用现有出版物、列表和数据库识别有儿童强制疫苗接种政策的国家,并进行多国检索和政策细节验证。
- 针对每个有儿童疫苗接种强制令的国家,使用现有研究和数据库/互联网检索调查其补偿方案。
主要发现
- 共识别62个有儿童强制疫苗接种政策的国家。
- 仅7个(11%)国家有证据表明同时实施了无过错补偿方案。
临床怎么用
- 预防医学与公共卫生工作者在推动强制疫苗接种政策时,应关注是否配套无过错补偿方案以维护社会契约。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: To prevent the spread of infectious diseases, governments have implemented a number of policies, including a range of mandatory vaccination policies. In addition, some governments have implemented no fault vaccine injury compensation schemes as a legal mechanism of recourse for individuals experiencing adverse events following vaccination. We aimed to identify countries with mandatory vaccination policies that also have no fault compensation schemes. METHODS: To identify countries with mandatory childhood vaccination policies, we utilized existing publications, lists and databases, also conducting multiple country searches and policy detail verification. We then investigated compensation schemes for each country with childhood vaccination mandates, using an existing study and database/internet searches. RESULTS: Of the 62 countries we identified with mandatory childhood vaccination policies, we found evidence that only 7 (11%) had also implemented no fault compensation schemes. CONCLUSIONS: No-fault compensation schemes are one government approach to address unintended consequences of vaccination. Few countries have implemented these schemes, including those with mandatory vaccination policies. Mandatory vaccination invokes a strong need to protect those who fall victim to extremely rare cases of provable no-fault vaccine injury. Countries that mandate childhood vaccination without providing no fault compensation schemes could be seen as abrogating the social contract. This is particularly important when public policies limit parental choice regarding whether to vaccinate.
引用
- Attwell K, Drislane S, Leask J, et al. Mandatory vaccination and no fault vaccine injury compensation schemes: An identification of country-level policies. Vaccine. 2019. PMID: 31000414. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2019.03.065
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。