南非疫苗决策驱动因素:一项离散选择实验
研究于2017年12月在南非对1200名参与者开展离散选择实验,考察疫苗有效性、疾病负担、可及性、轻度副作用频率、人群覆盖率和本地覆盖率六项属性对接种决策的影响。采用面板混合Logit模型分析,发现疫苗有效性最重要,其次为人群覆盖率和疾病负担。
要点
- 疫苗有效性是接种决策最重要的驱动因素
- 人群覆盖率和疾病负担紧随其后,本地覆盖率和可及性也重要
- 疾病严重程度比疾病发生频率对决策影响更大
核心结论
- 疫苗有效性是南非疫苗决策最重要的属性,其次为人群覆盖率和疾病负担。
- 人群和本地覆盖率对疫苗效用有正向影响,提示同伴影响/社会规范可被利用。
- 疾病严重程度比疾病发生频率对边际效用影响更大。
研究设计与样本
- 2017年12月在南非开展的离散选择实验,共1200名参与者。
- 考察六项属性:疫苗有效性、疫苗可预防疾病负担、可及性(共付和处方要求)、轻度副作用频率、人群接种覆盖率、本地接种覆盖率。
- 区分为自己接种和为最小孩子接种两类决策,采用面板混合Logit模型分析。
主要发现
- 为自己或为孩子接种的决策结果相似。
- 疫苗有效性是最重要属性,其次为人群覆盖率和疾病负担。
- 本地覆盖率和可及性也是重要决定因素,但程度较低。
- 人群和本地覆盖率对疫苗效用呈正向效应,提示同伴影响潜力。
- 疾病严重程度比疾病频率更重要。
临床怎么用
- 政策制定者和卫生工作者应强调疫苗有效性及疫苗可预防疾病的严重程度。
- 可利用社会规范影响提升疫苗接种信心和覆盖率。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
To increase vaccination coverage, it is essential to understand the vaccine decision-making process. High population coverage is required to obtain herd immunity and to protect vulnerable groups in terms of age (e.g. the very young) or health (e.g. immunodeficiency). Vaccine confidence and coverage in South Africa are relatively low, opening the window for sustained outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases in a country facing one of the most severe HIV epidemics in the world. To capture the vaccine-related decision-making process in South Africa, we performed a discrete choice experiment with 1200 participants in December 2017. We asked for their preferences with respect to (1) vaccine effectiveness, (2) vaccine-preventable burden of disease, (3) accessibility of the vaccine in terms of co-payment and prescription requirements, (4) frequency of mild vaccine-related side-effects, (5) population vaccination coverage and (6) local vaccination coverage. We distinguished between decision-making for vaccines administered to the participant, and for vaccines administered to their youngest child. We analyzed the data for each of these groups using a panel mixed logit model and found similar results for decisions to vaccinate oneself or one's child. Vaccine effectiveness was the most important attribute followed by population coverage and burden of disease. Local coverage and accessibility were also important determinants of vaccination behavior, but to a lesser extent. Regarding population and local coverage, we observed a positive effect on vaccine utility indicating the potential of peer influence. As such, social normative influence could be exploited to increase vaccination confidence and coverage. With respect to vaccine-preventable burden of the disease, the marginal utilities showed disease severity to be more important than frequency of disease. Policymakers and health care workers should stress the effectiveness of vaccines together with the severity of vaccine-preventable diseases.
引用
- Verelst F, Kessels R, Delva W, et al. Drivers of vaccine decision-making in South Africa: A discrete choice experiment. Vaccine. 2019. PMID: 30857931. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2019.02.056
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。