YouTube上支持与反对疫苗接种情绪的表述分析
研究系统抽样分析YouTube上流感与麻疹免疫接种视频,比较支持与反对免疫接种情绪的表述。发现两类视频均常见,但反对免疫接种情绪的视频更易被「点赞」,且少量词汇可有效识别反对内容。提示公共卫生专家或需提升其在YouTube内容的可见度。
要点
- 支持与反对免疫接种的视频在YouTube上均常见。
- 反对免疫接种情绪的视频更倾向于获得更多「点赞」。
- 少量词汇即可有效识别反对免疫接种内容。
核心结论
- YouTube上支持与反对免疫接种的视频均常见,但反对免疫接种情绪的视频更易被「点赞」。
- 少量词汇可有效识别反对免疫接种内容,或有助于追踪社交媒体上的反免疫趋势。
- 公共卫生专家或需提升其在YouTube内容的可见度,并探索改善公众对支持免疫接种信息态度的策略。
研究设计与样本
- 研究对YouTube上流感与麻疹免疫接种视频进行系统抽样分析,比较支持与反对免疫接种情绪的表述,分析维度包括观众分析数据和语言选择。
主要发现
- 支持与反对免疫接种的视频均常见。
- 反对免疫接种情绪的视频更倾向于被「点赞」。
- 少量词汇可有效用于识别反对免疫接种内容。
临床怎么用
- 公共卫生专家可考虑提升其在YouTube上支持免疫接种内容的可见度。
- 可利用少量关键词汇识别社交媒体上的反对免疫接种内容趋势。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Billions of hours of YouTube content are viewed every day. Much of this content is aimed at entertainment, some of it is educational, and a considerable quantity is meant to influence or reinforce public opinion on a variety of matters, including health. Most of the content on YouTube is not created by professionals, public institutions or the traditional media, and instead is authored by private individual content creators. Given the potential impact of this medium for communicating health information, it is important for researchers and public health practitioners to understand the nature of health information as it is shared on YouTube. The primary objective of this research is to describe expressions of vaccine hesitancy content on YouTube, and specifically, compare the expression of pro- and anti-immunization sentiments. We do this by not only analyzing a systematic sample of influenza and measles immunization videos in terms of viewer analytics, but also by choice of language. We find that pro- and anti-immunization videos are common, but that videos with anti-immunization sentiment tend to be more 'liked'. We also find that a small number of words can be effectively used to identify anti-immunization content, an observation that could be useful for identifying trends in anti-immunization sentiment on social media. Our results suggest that public health experts may need to increase the profile of their content on YouTube, and that there may be some useful strategies for improving the public's disposition towards pro-immunization messaging.
引用
- Yiannakoulias N, Slavik CE, Chase M, et al. Expressions of pro- and anti-vaccine sentiment on YouTube. Vaccine. 2019. PMID: 30862365. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2019.03.001
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。