文献速递免疫规划传染病防控与疫情报告

巴基斯坦城郊疫苗覆盖率快速入户调查三种抽样方法的比较

Comparison of three rapid household survey sampling methods for vaccination coverage assessment in a peri-urban setting in Pakistan.
PubMed 文献 · Int J Epidemiol · 2019-01-01

该研究于2016年在巴基斯坦卡拉奇城郊开展等样本量的前瞻性疫苗覆盖率调查,比较传统EPI整群抽样、紧凑片段抽样和基于网格的GIS抽样三种方法。结果显示三种方法的疫苗覆盖率估计无差异,但紧凑片段(DEFF=2.03)和GIS(DEFF=1.72)的设计效应高于EPI(DEFF=1.57),达到同等表观精度所需的实施时间更长。作者认为替代方法虽精度表观较低,但选择偏倚风险更低,可能更优。

要点

  • 三种抽样方法的疫苗覆盖率估计在城郊环境无差异。
  • 紧凑片段(DEFF=2.03)和GIS(DEFF=1.72)设计效应高于EPI(DEFF=1.57)。
  • 替代方法选择偏倚风险更低,可能更优。

核心结论

  • 在巴基斯坦城郊,三种抽样方法的疫苗覆盖率估计无差异,但替代方法设计效应更高、统计精度表观更低。
  • EPI调查表观精度较高可能源于有问题的自加权假设未计入可变抽样权重。
  • 紧凑片段和GIS方法选择偏倚风险更低,可能更优。

研究设计与样本

  • 比较传统EPI整群抽样、紧凑片段抽样和基于网格的GIS抽样三种方法。

主要发现

  • 三种抽样方法的疫苗覆盖率估计在城郊环境无差异。
  • 紧凑片段设计效应DEFF=2.03,GIS设计效应DEFF=1.72,传统EPI设计效应DEFF=1.57。
  • 紧凑片段调查达到同等表观精度所需实施时间超过传统EPI调查的两倍。

临床怎么用

  • 在城郊疫苗覆盖率监测中,可考虑使用紧凑片段或GIS抽样以降低选择偏倚风险。
  • 选择替代方法时需权衡其更高的设计效应和更长的实施时间。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Household surveys are an essential tool for vaccine coverage monitoring in developing countries, and the World Health Organization (WHO) Expanded Program on Immunization (EPI) cluster survey design has been a default choice for decades. In response to methodological limitations of the traditional EPI sampling, alternative methods have been proposed, based on modern statistical and geographical techniques. This study compared the coverage estimates and the time efficiency of the EPI sampling design and two alternative methods: the compact segment sampling and innovative grid-based geographical information system (GIS) sampling. METHODS: We conducted a series of equal-sized concurrent prospective vaccine coverage surveys in Karachi, Pakistan, from January to December 2016, using traditional EPI, compact segment and grid-based GIS sampling methods. RESULTS: No differences in vaccine coverage estimates were identified across sampling methods in the peri-urban setting; however, due to stronger clustering effects and correct incorporation of sampling weights, the compact segment [design effect (DEFF) = 2.03] and the grid-based GIS surveys (DEFF = 1.72) had higher design effects and, therefore, appeared to have lower statistical precision than the traditional EPI surveys (DEFF = 1.57). To achieve the same level of apparent precision, data collection activities in the compact segment surveys would require more than twice the implementation time needed compared with the traditional EPI surveys. CONCLUSIONS: The precision of the EPI surveys appeared higher than that of the alternative methods because, under a questionable self-weighting assumption, the estimated design effect did not account for variable sampling weights. The compact segment and grid-based GIS methods were designed to improve randomness and representativeness of sampling households. Although these alternative methods did not result in coverage estimates that differed from the EPI survey results in the peri-urban setting, they have a lower risk of selection bias and therefore may be preferred.

来源:Int J Epidemiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Gong W, Taighoon Shah M, Firdous S, et al. Comparison of three rapid household survey sampling methods for vaccination coverage assessment in a peri-urban setting in Pakistan. Int J Epidemiol. 2019. PMID: 30508112. doi:10.1093/ije/dyy263

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。