青少年自主同意接种疫苗的障碍与促进因素:混合方法证据合成
尽管多国法律允许有能力的青少年自主同意接种,但地方政策、专业人员对法律框架的误解及接种服务背景可阻碍实施;保护青少年健康的动机提高可接受性,但维护专业声誉或与家长关系可能阻碍实施,且维持家长决策角色常优先于赋权青少年自主同意。
要点
- 国家政策支持青少年自主同意接种,但地方政策与专业人员误解法律框架可阻碍实施。
- 保护青少年健康的动机提高自主同意可接受性,但维护专业声誉或家长关系可能阻碍实施。
- 维持家长作为儿童医疗决策者的角色常优先于赋权青少年自主同意。
核心结论
- 青少年自主同意接种程序的实施障碍影响青少年健康与疫苗接种规划 uptake。
- 需要明确政策框架并挑战家长同意的优先地位。
研究设计与样本
- 采用主题合成法解释与合并定性数据,定量数据在定性框架内整合。
主要发现
- 识别出三个主题:政策框架、保护与自主决定。
- 尽管有支持性国家政策框架,地方政策、专业人员对法律框架的误解及接种规划实施背景可阻碍青少年自主同意程序。
- 保护青少年健康的动机提高青少年自主同意的可接受性,但为保护专业声誉或与家长关系可能阻碍实施。
- 维持家长作为儿童医疗决策者的角色常优先于赋权青少年自主同意。
临床怎么用
- 实施青少年自主同意接种时需澄清政策框架,并应对地方政策与专业人员对法律框架的误解。
- 在保护青少年健康与维护专业声誉、家长关系之间需平衡,以促进自主同意程序落地。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: The recent global expansion of routine adolescent vaccination programmes has the potential to protect young people against infectious diseases and improve their health. Although the legal framework in many countries permits young people to consent for vaccinations if competent, lack of written parental consent can still prevent uptake. We aimed to review systematically the associated barriers and enablers to implementation of adolescent self-consent procedures. METHODS: A comprehensive search strategy of ten databases from inception to June 2018 was undertaken to identify relevant qualitative and quantitative studies. Titles, abstracts and full texts were assessed for eligibility, and the methodological quality of eligible primary studies evaluated. Thematic synthesis methods were used to interpret and combine qualitative data, and to identify overarching themes as well as similarities and differences within themes. Quantitative data were summarised and, because the data were sufficiently similar in focus, were integrated within the qualitative framework. RESULTS: Twenty-five publications related to 23 studies were included. Three themes were identified which related to the policy framework, protection, and self-determination. Despite supportive national policy frameworks, implementation of adolescent self-consent procedures can be prevented by local policies, professionals' misunderstandings of the legal framework and the context in which the vaccination programme is delivered. Motivation to protect young people's health increased acceptability of adolescent self-consent, but implementation might be prevented to protect the reputation of professionals or relationships with parents. Further, maintaining the role of parents as decision-makers for their child's healthcare was frequently prioritised over enabling young people's autonomy to consent. CONCLUSIONS: Barriers to the implementation of adolescent self-consent procedures have implications for young people's health and uptake of vaccination programmes. There is a need to clarify the policy framework and challenge the primacy of parental consent. SYSTEMATIC REVIEW REGISTRATION: PROSPERO CRD42017084509.
引用
- Fisher H, Harding S, Hickman M, et al. Barriers and enablers to adolescent self-consent for vaccination: A mixed-methods evidence synthesis. Vaccine. 2018. PMID: 30573357. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2018.12.007
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。