文献速递营养与食品安全卫生政策与健康促进

州级优先立法对食品营养政策与诉讼的限制:削弱政府在公共卫生中的作用

State Preemption of Food and Nutrition Policies and Litigation: Undermining Government's Role in Public Health.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Prev Med · 2018-11-19

该研究于2018年通过州立法机构网站、LexisNexis等数据库检索截至2018年3月16日的州法律,分析州级优先立法对地方食品营养政策及食品消费相关诉讼的限制。结果发现2008年至2018年间12个州颁布了13项优先立法,2003年至2013年间26个州颁布了优先食品消费诉讼的法律。结论认为州级优先立法可能阻碍地方公共卫生政策推进和政府诉讼。

要点

  • 12个州颁布13项优先立法,限制地方食品营养政策
  • 26个州立法优先于食品消费致肥胖相关诉讼
  • 州级优先立法可能削弱地方政府解决健康差距的能力

核心结论

  • 州级优先立法可能通过阻碍地方食品营养政策和政府诉讼而妨碍公共卫生进展。

研究设计与样本

  • 2018年通过州立法机构网站、LexisNexis、UConn Rudd Center立法数据库、CDC慢性病州政策追踪系统及互联网检索截至2018年3月16日颁布的州法律及其立法历史。

主要发现

  • 2008年至2018年3月16日,12个州颁布了13项优先立法,涉及营养标签、内容或标准、消费者激励项目、食品相关健康差异、食品饮料销售分销或供应、份量、食品安全、菜单、税收和营销。
  • 2003年至2013年,26个州颁布法律优先于声称长期食品消费导致肥胖和饮食相关疾病的诉讼。

临床怎么用

  • 地方政府在减少健康差异、提供营养信息、促进健康食品可及性和降低不健康食品成本方面具有关键地位。
  • 政府提起的诉讼可能支持更广泛的政策变革。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

INTRODUCTION: In the U.S., federal, state, and local governments have various legal tools to support public health and prevent diet-related disease, including enacting policy and bringing lawsuits against businesses that produce harm-causing products. Yet, states preempt, or limit, government's authority to enact public health policies or initiate litigation. METHODS: In 2018, research was conducted to find state laws enacted through March 16, 2018, using state legislatures' websites, LexisNexis, UConn Rudd Center's Legislative Database, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Chronic Disease State Policy Tracking System, and the Internet, that preempt local food and nutrition policies including their legislative histories; and preempt lawsuits related to food consumption and chronic disease (e.g., Commonsense Consumption Acts), including explicitly preempting government activity. RESULTS: Between 2008 and March 16, 2018, 12 states enacted 13 preemptive laws on nutrition labeling, content or "criteria"; consumer incentive items; "food-based health disparities"; sale, distribution, or serving of food and beverages; portion size; food safety; menus; taxes; and "marketing." Between 2003 and 2013, 26 states enacted laws preempting lawsuits claiming long-term food consumption causes obesity and diet-related disease; of these, ten states explicitly preempt such litigation by the government and five explicitly preempt laws providing litigation as a remedy. CONCLUSIONS: State preemption may hinder public health progress by impeding local food and nutrition policies and government-initiated litigation. Local governments are in a prime position to address fundamental concerns, such as reduction of health disparities, the provision of nutrition information, access to healthy food, and the cost of unhealthy food. Government-initiated litigation could potentially support broader policy changes.

来源:Am J Prev Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Pomeranz JL, Zellers L, Bare M, et al. State Preemption of Food and Nutrition Policies and Litigation: Undermining Government's Role in Public Health. Am J Prev Med. 2018. PMID: 30467091. doi:10.1016/j.amepre.2018.07.027

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。