秘鲁与墨西哥免疫数据质量改进:两项案例研究的挑战与经验
该研究以案例研究方式分析墨西哥电子免疫登记系统(EIR)与秘鲁人口登记系统的实施经验,资料来自技术文件、利益相关者焦点小组、现场访问与半结构化访谈。墨西哥早期EIR因资源不足与数据登记实践不佳而停用;秘鲁系统在改善免疫等项目数据的同时强化了卫生系统。两国主要挑战涉及资金、治理结构与卫生工作者抵触。
要点
- 墨西哥EIR因资源不足与登记实践不佳而停用,提示可持续性风险。
- 秘鲁通过服务社会项目的信息系统改善免疫与人口数据质量。
- 实施前需确保充足资金、可持续规划与卫生工作者能力建设。
核心结论
- 墨西哥与秘鲁的案例表明,实施EIR前需确保充足资金、可持续规划与卫生工作者能力建设,并探索经济激励与链接其他卫生优先事项等新路径。
研究设计与样本
- 对墨西哥一个EIR与秘鲁一个人口登记系统开展案例研究,资料来自技术文件、利益相关者焦点小组、现场访问及对国家层面利益相关者的半结构化访谈。
主要发现
- 墨西哥建立了世界最早的EIR之一并具备地方层面患者追踪等新功能,但资源不足与数据登记实践不佳导致系统停用。
- 秘鲁建立信息系统以改善社会项目(含免疫项目)的加入与人口数据质量。
- 两国信息系统实施与可持续性的主要挑战涉及资金、清晰的治理结构及卫生工作者的抵触。
临床怎么用
- 在低中收入国家实施EIR前应规划充足资金与可持续性,并开展卫生工作者能力建设。
- 可考虑对次国家行政层级采用经济激励,并将免疫数据改进与其他卫生及政治优先事项链接。
局限性
- 原文指出,关于低中收入国家成功采纳与可持续实施免疫登记系统的最佳实践仍需更多信息。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: The Global Vaccine Action Plan and the Regional Immunization Action Plan of the Americas call for countries to improve immunization data quality. Immunization information systems, particularly electronic immunization registries (EIRs), can help to facilitate program management and increase coverage. However, little is known about efforts to develop and implement such systems in low- and middle-income countries. We present the experiences of Mexico and Peru in implementing EIRs. METHODS: We conducted case studies of an EIR in Mexico and of a population registry in Peru. Information was gathered from technical documents, stakeholder focus groups, site visits, and semi-structured interviews of national stakeholders. We organized findings into narratives that emphasized challenges and lessons learned. RESULTS: Mexico built one of the world's first EIRs, incorporating novel features such as local-level tracking of patients; however, insufficient resources and poor data registration practices led to the system's discontinuation. Peru created an information system to improve affiliation to social programs, including the immunization program and quality of demographic data. Mexico's experience highlights lessons in failed sustainability of an EIR and a laudable effort to reform a country's information system. Peru's demonstrates that attempts to improve health and other data may strengthen health systems, including immunization data. Major challenges in information system implementation and sustainability in Peru and Mexico related to funding, clear governance structures, and resistance among health workers. DISCUSSION: These case studies reinforce the need for countries to ensure adequate funding, plans for sustainability, and health worker capacity-building activities before implementing EIRs. They also suggest new approaches to implementation, including economic incentives for sub-national administrative levels and opportunities to link efforts to improve immunization data with other health and political priorities. More information on best practices is needed to ensure the successful adoption and sustainability of immunization registries in low- and middle-income countries.
引用
- Trumbo SP, Contreras M, García AGF, et al. Improving immunization data quality in Peru and Mexico: Two case studies highlighting challenges and lessons learned. Vaccine. 2018. PMID: 30414780. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2018.10.083
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。