肯尼亚疫苗登记系统揭示常规接种覆盖率估计的误差与及时性
BACKGROUND: The benefits of childhood vaccines are critically dependent on vaccination coverage. We used a vaccine registry (as gold standard) in Kenya to quantify errors in routine coverage methods (surveys and administrative reports), to estimate the magnitude of survivor bias,…
要点
- 12-23月龄儿童调查较出生队列高估覆盖率2%。
- 12月龄静态覆盖率较婴儿期平均覆盖率分别高估脊灰、五联和肺炎疫苗7-8%,麻疹疫苗24%。
- 调查和行政方法低估完全免疫儿童比例10-14%。
核心结论
- 常规12-23月龄儿童覆盖率调查忽略及时性和幸存者/回忆偏倚,高估保护力。
- 延迟接种常见地区,实时覆盖率会偏倚人群免疫估计。
- 调查和行政方法低估完全免疫儿童比例。
研究设计与样本
- 分析49,090名婴儿和48,025名12-23月龄儿童,采用逆生存曲线估计覆盖率和及时性,Cox回归评估风险因素。
主要发现
- 12-23月龄儿童调查较出生队列高估覆盖率2%。
- 12月龄静态覆盖率较婴儿期平均覆盖率分别高估脊灰、五联和肺炎疫苗7-8%,麻疹疫苗24%。
- 调查和行政方法低估完全免疫儿童比例10-14%。
- BCG、五联和麻疹疫苗及时性在卫生机构出生儿童中高23-44%,在首次接种遇疫苗缺货儿童中低20-37%。
临床怎么用
- 评估人群免疫应结合及时性指标,而非仅用静态覆盖率。
- 常规调查和行政报告可能高估保护力并低估完全免疫比例,需谨慎解读。
局限性
- 研究基于肯尼亚KHDSS单一地区数据,外推需谨慎。
- 未报告调查和行政方法误差的具体机制。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The benefits of childhood vaccines are critically dependent on vaccination coverage. We used a vaccine registry (as gold standard) in Kenya to quantify errors in routine coverage methods (surveys and administrative reports), to estimate the magnitude of survivor bias, contrast coverage with timeliness and use both measures to estimate population immunity. METHODS: Vaccination records of children in the Kilifi Health and Demographic Surveillance System (KHDSS), Kenya were combined with births, deaths, migration and residence data from 2010 to 17. Using inverse survival curves, we estimated up-to-date and age-appropriate vaccination coverage, calculated mean vaccination coverage in infancy as the area under the inverse survival curves, and estimated the proportion of fully immunised children (FIC). Results were compared with published coverage estimates. Risk factors for vaccination were assessed using Cox regression models. RESULTS: We analysed data for 49,090 infants and 48,025 children aged 12-23 months in 6 birth cohorts and 6 cross-sectional surveys respectively, and found 2nd year of life surveys overestimated coverage by 2% compared to birth cohorts. Compared to mean coverage in infants, static coverage at 12 months was exaggerated by 7-8% for third doses of oral polio, pentavalent (Penta3) and pneumococcal conjugate vaccines, and by 24% for the measles vaccine. Surveys and administrative coverage also underestimated the proportion of the fully immunised child by 10-14%. For BCG, Penta3 and measles, timeliness was 23-44% higher in children born in a health facility but 20-37% lower in those who first attended during vaccine stock outs. CONCLUSIONS: Standard coverage surveys in 12-23 month old children overestimate protection by ignoring timeliness, and survivor and recall biases. Where delayed vaccination is common, up-to-date coverage will give biased estimates of population immunity. Surveys and administrative methods also underestimate FIC prevalence. Better measurement of coverage and more sophisticated analyses are required to control vaccine preventable diseases.
引用
- Adetifa IMO, Karia B, Mutuku A, et al. Coverage and timeliness of vaccination and the validity of routine estimates: Insights from a vaccine registry in Kenya. Vaccine. 2018. PMID: 30416017. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2018.11.005
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。