顺势疗法疫苗与常规疫苗抗体应答的随机盲法安慰剂对照试验
该随机盲法安慰剂对照试验纳入150名有童年疫苗接种史的大学生,比较顺势疗法疫苗、安慰剂与常规Tdap/MMR疫苗的抗体应答。结果显示顺势疗法疫苗组与安慰剂组均无≥2倍抗体应答,而常规疫苗组多数产生显著抗体应答(p<0.001)。结论认为顺势疗法疫苗不引发抗体反应,效果与安慰剂相似。
要点
- 顺势疗法疫苗组与安慰剂组均无≥2倍抗体应答。
- 常规Tdap组对白喉、百日咳、破伤风的应答率分别为68%、83%、88%。
- 常规MMR组对麻疹或腮腺炎抗原的应答率为35%。
核心结论
- 顺势疗法疫苗不引发抗体应答,效果与安慰剂相似;常规疫苗在多数受种者中产生稳健抗体应答。
研究设计与样本
- 随机盲法安慰剂对照试验,纳入150名有童年疫苗接种史的大学生,分组接受顺势疗法疫苗、安慰剂或常规Tdap及MMR疫苗。
主要发现
- 顺势疗法疫苗组和安慰剂组均无参与者对任何抗原出现≥2倍抗体应答。
- 常规Tdap组中68%(33/48)对白喉、83%(40/48)对百日咳类毒素、88%(42/48)对破伤风出现≥2倍应答。
- 常规MMR组中35%(17/48)对麻疹或腮腺炎抗原出现应答。
- 常规疫苗组抗体几何平均滴度较基线显著升高(各抗原p<0.001),顺势疗法疫苗组和安慰剂组无显著变化。
关键数值与推荐
- 主要结局为ELISA测定的疫苗接种后抗体较基线≥2倍升高。
- 常规疫苗与顺势疗法疫苗或安慰剂比较,各抗原应答差异均p<0.001。
临床怎么用
- 不应使用顺势疗法疫苗替代常规疫苗进行免疫预防。
- 常规Tdap和MMR疫苗在多数年轻成人中可有效诱导抗体应答。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Homeopathic vaccines are licensed in many countries but scientific data to support their use are sparse. The goal of this study was to compare the antibody response of homeopathic and conventional vaccines and placebo in young adults. We hypothesized that there would be no significant difference between homeopathic vaccines and placebo, while there would be a significant increase in antibodies in those received conventional vaccines. METHODS: A randomized blinded placebo-controlled trial was conducted where 150 university students who had received childhood vaccinations were assigned to diphtheria, pertussis, tetanus, mumps, measles homeopathic vaccine, placebo, or conventional diphtheria, pertussis, tetanus (Tdap) and mumps, measles, rubella (MMR) vaccines. The primary outcome was a ≥ two-fold increase in antibodies from baseline following vaccination as measured by ELISA. Participants, investigators, study coordinator, data blood drawers, laboratory technician, and data analyst were blinded. RESULTS: None of the participants in either the homeopathic vaccine or the placebo group showed a ≥ two-fold response to any of the antigens. In contrast, of those vaccinated with Tdap, 68% (33/48) had a ≥ two-fold response to diphtheria, 83% (40/48) to pertussis toxoid, 88% (42/48) to tetanus, and 35% (17/48) of those vaccinated with MMR had a response to measles or mumps antigens (p < 0.001 for each comparison of conventional vaccine to homeopathic vaccine or to placebo). There was a significant increase in geometric mean titres of antibody from baseline for conventional vaccine antigens (p < 0.001 for each), but none for the response to homeopathic antigens or placebo. CONCLUSIONS: Homeopathic vaccines do not evoke antibody responses and produce a response that is similar to placebo. In contrast, conventional vaccines provide a robust antibody response in the majority of those vaccinated. TRIAL REGISTRY: NCT 02825368.
引用
- Loeb M, Russell ML, Neupane B, et al. A randomized, blinded, placebo-controlled trial comparing antibody responses to homeopathic and conventional vaccines in university students. Vaccine. 2018. PMID: 30352746. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2018.08.082
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。