运动对疫苗接种后局部和全身不良反应的影响:两项随机对照试验结果
两项随机对照试验分别纳入116名接种HPV疫苗的青少年和78名接种流感疫苗的年轻成人,评估接种前或接种后15分钟上肢或下肢运动对自报不良反应的影响。结果显示运动可减少部分局部和全身不良反应报告天数,女性青少年报告的不良反应天数总体多于男性。
要点
- 接种前15分钟上肢运动可减少女性青少年HPV疫苗接种后压痛报告天数。
- 接种前后15分钟手臂或腿部运动可减少流感疫苗接种后肿胀、发热和食欲下降报告天数。
- 女性青少年报告疼痛、压痛、肿胀和不适的天数显著多于男性。
核心结论
- 短期运动可减少疫苗接种后部分局部和全身不良反应的报告天数。
- 青少年中不良反应报告天数的性别差异比年轻成人更明显。
研究设计与样本
- 研究一:116名接种HPV疫苗的青少年随机分为对照组(n=56)和接种前运动组(n=60),运动为15分钟上肢运动,2015-2016年开展。
- 研究二:78名接种流感疫苗的年轻成人随机分为对照组(n=19)、接种前手臂运动组(n=19)、接种前腿部运动组(n=20)或接种后手臂运动组(n=20),运动为15分钟手臂或腿部运动,2017年开展。
- 两项研究中所有参与者均在接种后7天内填写不良反应日记。
主要发现
- 研究一:运动组女性青少年报告的压痛天数显著低于对照组(p=0.032),疼痛天数呈相似趋势(p=0.050)。
- 研究一:运动组报告的不适天数(p=0.070)和食欲下降天数(p=0.067)较低,但未达统计学显著。
- 研究一:女性青少年报告的疼痛(p=0.003)、压痛(p<0.001)、肿胀(p=0.011)和不适(p=0.0040)天数显著更多。
- 研究二:运动组两性报告的肿胀(p=0.018)、发热(p=0.013)和食欲下降(p=0.011)天数减少。
- 研究二:女性运动组报告用药天数减少(p=0.034),肿胀天数呈减少趋势(p=0.052)。
临床怎么用
- 接种前或接种后进行15分钟上肢或下肢运动可能有助于减少部分疫苗接种后不良反应的报告天数。
- 对女性青少年接种HPV疫苗时,可考虑将短期运动作为减少局部反应的辅助措施。
局限性
- 两项试验样本量较小,结果需进一步验证。
- 不良反应为自报结局,可能存在报告偏倚。
- 运动类型、时机和人群差异对结果的影响尚需更多研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: An adverse reaction associated with vaccination is considered to be a key barrier to vaccinate, yet little attention has been given to interventions to reduce their occurrence. Exercise is a behavioural adjuvant which may also influence adverse reactions. Here, two randomized controlled trials are reported, examining the effects of exercise on self-reported adverse reactions following vaccination in adolescents and young adults. METHODS: Study one; 116 adolescents receiving the HPV vaccine were randomly allocated to either Control (n = 56) or Pre-vaccine Exercise (n = 60) group (2015-2016). Exercise consisted of 15-minutes upper body exercise. Study two; 78 young adults receiving the influenza vaccine were randomly allocated to either Control (n = 19), or one of 3 exercise groups: Pre-vaccine Arm (n = 19), Pre-vaccine Leg (n = 20) or Post-vaccine Arm (n = 20) (2017). Exercise included 15-minutes of arm or leg exercises prior to or after vaccination. All participants in both studies completed an adverse events diary for seven-days post-vaccination. RESULTS: Study one; Reported days of tenderness in female adolescents that exercised were significantly lower than control (p = 0.032), with a similar trend in reported days of pain (p = 0.050). Furthermore, days of feeling ill (p = 0.070) and reduced appetite (p = 0.067) were found to be lower with exercise, although not significant. Overall, female adolescents reported significantly more days of pain (p = 0.003), tenderness (p < 0.001), swelling (p = 0.011), and feeling ill (p = 0.0040). Study two; Exercise groups reported reduced days of swelling (p = 0.018), fever (p = 0.013), and lowered appetite (p = 0.011) across both genders. Furthermore, females reported reduced days of medication use with exercise (p = 0.034), and a trend toward reduced days of swelling (p = 0.052). DISCUSSION: In two separate trials, a short bout of exercise reduced reported adverse reactions after vaccinations for local and systemic adverse reactions. Gender differences in reported local and systemic adverse reactions were more evident among adolescents than young adults. These findings support the need for further work to examine the potential benefit of exercise in improving vaccination procedures.
引用
- Lee VY, Booy R, Skinner SR, et al. The effect of exercise on local and systemic adverse reactions after vaccinations - Outcomes of two randomized controlled trials. Vaccine. 2018. PMID: 30301642. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2018.09.067
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。