丹麦HPV疫苗接种后疑似不良事件报告决定因素分析
研究向251名报告严重疑似不良事件的已接种HPV疫苗女性及1003名随机选择的已接种对照发放问卷,比较人口学、生活方式与健康相关因素。接种前自报精神或躯体状况无显著差异;更多病例报告首次接种前体力非常活跃(OR 4.2),而较少病例有时(OR 0.31)或经常/总是(OR 0.36)感到悲伤。作者指出该结果与近期丹麦登记库病例对照研究结论不一致。
要点
- 接种前自报精神或躯体状况在病例与对照间无显著差异。
- 更多病例报告首次HPV接种前体力非常活跃(OR 4.2)。
- 较少病例有时(OR 0.31)或经常/总是(OR 0.36)感到悲伤。
核心结论
- 报告严重疑似不良事件的女性在接种前自报精神或躯体状况与对照无显著差异,但体力活动水平和悲伤情绪报告频率存在差异。
- 该结果与近期丹麦登记库病例对照研究结论不一致,作者认为本研究有助于理解受影响女性对接种前后日常生活的解读。
研究设计与样本
- 问卷调查研究,向251名报告严重疑似不良事件的已接种HPV疫苗女性病例和1003名从丹麦疫苗接种登记库随机选择的已接种对照发放问卷。
- 问卷聚焦人口学、生活方式和健康相关问题;所有研究对象均已接种HPV疫苗。
主要发现
- 接种前自报精神或躯体状况测量无显著差异。
- 更多病例报告首次HPV疫苗接种前体力非常活跃(OR 4.2)。
- 较对照,较少病例有时感到悲伤(OR 0.31)或经常/总是感到悲伤(OR 0.36)。
局限性
- 原文未述局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
HPV vaccination has been offered to 12-year-old girls as part of the Danish Childhood Vaccination Programme since 2009. From 2013, an increasing number of suspected severe adverse events (AE) without a documented causal link to the vaccine was observed, resulting in public concerns about vaccine safety and a decline in uptake. This study aimed at describing the group of females reporting AE and comparing them to vaccinated peers not reporting AE. A questionnaire focusing on demographics, lifestyle, and health-related issues was distributed to 251 female cases who had reported severe AE and 1,003 female controls randomly selected from the population-based Danish Vaccination Registry. All had been HPV-vaccinated. There were no significant differences on measures of self-reported psychiatric or somatic conditions before vaccination. More cases reported being physically very active prior to first HPV vaccination (OR 4.2) whereas fewer cases than controls sometimes (OR 0.31) or often/always (OR 0.36) felt sad. This is unexpected because two recent Danish registry-based case-control studies concluded that females reporting severe AE were more likely to consult a psychologist/psychiatrist and to have pre-existing psychiatric conditions before first HPV vaccination. One of these studies also showed that cases had increased health-care seeking regarding a number of somatic conditions prior to first vaccination. Our study adds value when seeking to understand the lifeworld of the affected females and their interpretations of their everyday lives pre- and post-HPV vaccination.
引用
- Ulendorf Jacobsen S, Valentiner-Branth P, Mølbak K, et al. Examining determinants for reporting suspected adverse events following HPV vaccination in Denmark. Vaccine. 2018. PMID: 30201304. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2018.08.061
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。