国家免疫技术咨询小组在强化国家疫苗决策中的作用:亚美尼亚、加纳、印度尼西亚、尼日利亚、塞内加尔和乌干达的比较案例研究
该混合方法案例系列研究通过半结构化访谈、会议观察和文件审查,考察了六个中低收入国家国家免疫技术咨询小组(NITAG)的功能、建议制定质量及与国家决策机构的整合情况。五个NITAG已依法设立并运作良好,加纳的NITAG尚在发展中;所有NITAG均有标准操作程序和提名程序,被视作与卫生部决策良好整合,但地位仍不稳固,需要可持续的技术和财政支持。
要点
- 五个NITAG已依法设立并运作良好,加纳的NITAG尚在发展中。
- 所有NITAG均有标准操作程序和提名程序以确保专业知识范围。
- NITAG被视作与卫生部决策良好整合,但地位仍不稳固,需要可持续支持。
核心结论
- NITAG在国家免疫决策中具有重要且受重视的作用,但其地位仍不稳固,需要可持续的技术和财政支持。
研究设计与样本
- 采用混合方法案例系列设计,使用半结构化访谈、NITAG会议观察和文件审查,数据按主题分析。
- 研究考察了亚美尼亚、加纳、印度尼西亚、尼日利亚、塞内加尔和乌干达六个中低收入国家的NITAG。
主要发现
- 五个NITAG已依法设立并有职权范围,似运作良好,加纳的NITAG尚在发展中。
- 所有NITAG均有标准操作程序和提名程序以确保专业知识范围,一般包括10-15名核心成员、1-5名秘书处成员和若干当然成员。
- 除经济学外,NITAG报告了广泛的成员专业知识;较新的NITAG尤其关注资金问题。
- 四个NITAG使用了正式的利益冲突程序,尽管一些评论称其影响并不总是被理解。
- NITAG重视本地数据,有限证据提示NITAG的存在可能通过监测和本地研究加强数据生产。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Improving evidence informed decision-making in immunisation is a global health priority and many low and middle-income countries have established National Immunisation Technical Advisory Groups (NITAGs) as independent technical advisory bodies for this purpose. NITAG development and strengthening has received financial and technical support over the past decade, but relatively little evaluation. This study examined NITAGs in six low and middle-income countries (i.e. Armenia, Ghana, Indonesia, Nigeria, Senegal, Uganda), to examine functionality, quality of recommendation development, and integration with national decision-making bodies and processes. METHODS: A mixed-method case-series design, used semi-structured interviews, NITAG meeting observations, and document review. Data were analysed thematically. RESULTS: Five NITAGs had been legally established with terms of reference and appeared well functioning, with Ghana's in development. All NITAGs had standard operating procedures and nomination procedures to ensure a range of expertise, generally comprising 10-15 core, 1-5 secretariat, and several ex-officio members. Aside from economics, NITAGs reported a wide range of member expertise. Newer NITAGs had particular concerns about funding. Four used formal conflict of interest procedures, although some commented that implications were not always understood. NITAGs valued local data, and limited evidence suggested NITAG presence might reinforce data production through surveillance and local research studies. All observed meetings demonstrated due process and evidence-based decision-making processes were generally followed, with a critical role played by working-group data syntheses and assessments. NITAGs were seen as well integrated with ministry of health (MoH) decision-making and MoH interviewees were positive about NITAG contributions, indicating NITAGs had an important role. Collaboration with other bodies was more limited, but mitigated by NITAG members' cross-membership in other bodies. CONCLUSIONS: NITAGs have an important and valued role within national immunisation decision-making. However, their position remains insecure, with the need for sustainable technical and financial support.
引用
- Howard N, Walls H, Bell S, et al. The role of National Immunisation Technical Advisory Groups (NITAGs) in strengthening national vaccine decision-making: A comparative case study of Armenia, Ghana, Indonesia, Nigeria, Senegal and Uganda. Vaccine. 2018. PMID: 30076103. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2018.07.063
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。