美国老年人流感疫苗季内保护力衰减提示延迟接种可能带来净获益
研究利用2010/2011至2015/2016流感季的历史数据建模,评估美国≥65岁老年人调整流感疫苗接种时机的影响。结果显示,在保护力较快衰减(26周)假设下,估计最优开始接种周可预防当前疾病负担的3.69%至11.97%,提示适度延迟接种可能有益。
要点
- 在保护力较慢衰减(52周)假设下,估计最优开始接种时间因流感季而异,可预防当前疾病负担的0.44%至5.11%。
- 在保护力较快衰减(26周)假设下,估计最优开始接种周为2012-2013年第37周至2011-2012年第47周,可预防3.69%至11.97%的当前疾病负担。
- 作者认为,由于各流感季时间变异大,难以确定理想开始接种时间,但缩短接种与流感活动间隔可能带来实质性获益。
核心结论
- 由于各流感季时间变异大,难以确定理想开始接种时间,但研究发现缩短美国老年人接种与流感活动间隔可能带来实质性获益。
- 在评估的流感季中,适度延迟免疫接种有益;若进一步证据提示保护力快速衰减,可能需更长时间延迟,因这些情景下当前接种时机常非常不理想。
研究设计与样本
- 利用2010/2011至2015/2016流感季的流感活动与疫苗接种数据,建模评估美国≥65岁老年人开始接种流感疫苗的最优时间,通过估计当前疾病负担的百分比变化来量化改变接种时机的影响。
主要发现
- 在保护力较慢衰减(52周)假设下,估计最优开始接种时间因流感季而异,介于2012-2013年第34周(8月中旬)至2011-2012年第43周(10月中下旬),分别可预防当前疾病负担的0.44%和5.11%。
- 在保护力较快衰减(26周)假设下,估计最优开始接种周介于2012-2013年第37周(9月初)至2011-2012年第47周(11月中旬),分别可预防当前疾病负担的3.69%和11.97%。
关键数值与推荐
- 保护力较慢衰减(52周)假设下,最优开始接种周为第34周(2012-2013)至第43周(2011-2012),可预防当前疾病负担的0.44%至5.11%。
- 保护力较快衰减(26周)假设下,最优开始接种周为第37周(2012-2013)至第47周(2011-2012),可预防当前疾病负担的3.69%至11.97%。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: There is growing evidence that there is within (intra-) season waning of influenza vaccine protection in older adults, suggesting there may be a benefit to giving influenza vaccine closer to the time of increased infection risk. We aimed to quantitatively evaluate the impact of modifying the timing of influenza vaccination in U.S. older adults. METHODS: Using historical data (2010/2011-2015/2016, inclusive) on influenza activity and vaccine uptake, we explore the optimal time to begin vaccinating older adults (≥65 years) in the U.S. to maximize prevention of influenza. We modelled the effect of changing the timing of vaccination by estimating the percentage change to the current disease burden and used this to calculate the estimated optimal week to begin vaccination in the U.S. RESULTS: When we assumed a relatively slower waning protection rate (over 52 weeks), the estimated optimal time to begin vaccinating those aged ≥65 years varied between mid-August (week 34, 2012-2013) and mid-late October (week 43, 2011-2012) depending on the season, resulting in 0.44% and 5.11% of the current disease burden prevented respectively. Under faster waning (over 26 weeks), the estimated optimal week varied between early September (week 37, 2012-2013) and mid-November (week 47, 2011-2012), resulting in 3.69% and 11.97% of the current disease burden prevented respectively. CONCLUSIONS: While it is difficult to determine the ideal time to start to vaccinate due to substantial variation in timing of individual seasons, we found that there are potentially substantial benefits to minimizing the time between vaccination and influenza activity in U.S. older adults. Modest delays in immunization were beneficial in the seasons we evaluated. If further evidence suggests fast waning, longer delays may be warrant as in these scenarios the timing of the current vaccination was often very suboptimal.
引用
- Newall AT, Chen C, Wood JG, et al. Within-season influenza vaccine waning suggests potential net benefits to delayed vaccination in older adults in the United States. Vaccine. 2018. PMID: 30146403. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2018.08.007
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。