公立学校中的人体实验:20世纪学校如何成为疫苗试验场所
本文通过考察20世纪白喉、脊髓灰质炎和麻疹疫苗的学校试验,探讨以学校为试验场所的影响及三者的连续性与间断性。共同点是将决策带入公共领域,使家长承受社会压力及学校官员和社区成员的影响;但影响因疾病叙事、公众对医学科学认知及社会价值观不同而异。这些见解与当今全球健康研究中社区同意的复杂辩论相关。
要点
- 学校长期是公共卫生当局实现广泛疫苗接种的关键伙伴。
- 20世纪中期公立学校也曾作为新型疫苗大规模实验的场所。
- 以学校为试验场所使决策进入公共领域,家长承受社会压力及学校官员和社区成员的影响。
核心结论
- 以学校为疫苗试验场所不仅显示公共机构影响意见和认知的力量,也显示权威人物、同伴和社区成员可能给看似私人的决策过程带来微妙影响。
- 这些考量与当今健康干预相关,例如全球健康研究中关于社区同意的复杂辩论。
研究设计与样本
- 通过考察实验性白喉、脊髓灰质炎和麻疹疫苗试验,探讨以学校为试验场所的影响及三者的连续性与间断性。
主要发现
- 三项试验的共同点是使用学校将决策带入公共领域,使家长承受社会压力及学校官员和社区成员的影响。
- 使用学校的效果各异,因为学校的社会和制度意义与每种疾病的叙事、公众对医学和科学不断变化的认知以及社会不断变化的价值观发生不同互动。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Schools have long been critical partners for public health authorities in achieving widespread vaccination. In the mid-20th century, however, public schools also served as sites of large-scale experiments on novel vaccines. Through examining the experimental diphtheria, polio, and measles vaccine trials, I explored the implications of using schools in this manner, as well as the continuities and discontinuities among the three cases. Common to all of them was that the use of schools brought decision-making into the public sphere, subjecting parents to social pressures and the influences of school officials and community members. However, the effects of using schools varied as well, as their social and institutional significance interacted differently with the narratives surrounding each disease, the public's changing perception of medicine and science, and society's changing values. These insights show not only the power of public institutions to influence opinions and perceptions, but also the subtle forces that one's authority figures, peers, and community members may bring to a seemingly private decision-making process. These considerations are relevant to health interventions today, such as the complex debate over community consent in global health research. (Am J Public Health. 2018;108:1015-1022. doi: 10.2105/AJPH.2018.304423).
引用
- Schupmann WD. Human Experimentation in Public Schools: How Schools Served as Sites of Vaccine Trials in the 20th Century. Am J Public Health. 2018. PMID: 29927656. doi:10.2105/AJPH.2018.304423
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。