文献速递免疫规划卫生政策与健康促进

儿童疫苗接种调查中的照料者回忆:回忆质量及中低收入环境使用的系统综述

Caregiver recall in childhood vaccination surveys: Systematic review of recall quality and use in low- and middle-income settings.
PubMed 文献 · Vaccine · 2018-06-06

该系统综述检索Medline并筛选8篇文献,评估中低收入国家儿童疫苗接种覆盖调查中照料者回忆的质量。回忆敏感度为41-98%,特异度为12-80%,研究设计、回忆数据纳入方式和结局指标存在异质性,可靠性指标缺乏且无统一方法处理数据不完整。作者建议继续使用照料者回忆,并给出收集、分析与呈现的建议。

要点

  • 中低收入国家疫苗覆盖估计质量反复被证实较差,常依赖照料者回忆。
  • 纳入8篇文献中回忆敏感度41-98%、特异度12-80%,可靠性指标缺乏。
  • 作者建议对有疫苗记录者纳入回忆、插补缺失数据、子样本评估回忆与记录质量并行敏感性分析。

核心结论

  • 照料者回忆存在质量担忧,且因缺乏疫苗状态的「金标准」而难以评估。
  • 为改善覆盖估计和疫苗影响,应使用照料者回忆。
  • 其他建议包括:对有疫苗记录者纳入回忆、插补缺失数据、在子样本中评估回忆与记录质量、进行敏感性分析。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述,检索Medline,使用关键词组合:(child) AND (vaccinat*) AND (survey OR recall OR coverage) AND (reliab* OR valid*)。
  • 从1268篇文章中筛选134篇全文,最终纳入8篇评估中低收入国家回忆质量的文章。
  • 提取报告的效度、信度和完整性,并综合关于收集、分析和呈现照料者回忆的建议。

主要发现

  • 研究设计、回忆数据纳入方式和所测结局存在异质性。
  • 回忆的敏感度为41-98%。
  • 回忆的特异度为12-80%。
  • 可靠性指标缺乏,且无统一方法处理数据不完整。

关键数值与推荐

  • 回忆敏感度41-98%,特异度12-80%。
  • 建议对有疫苗记录者纳入回忆。
  • 建议插补缺失数据。
  • 建议在子样本中评估回忆与记录质量。
  • 建议进行敏感性分析。

临床怎么用

  • 作者建议照料者回忆应用于疫苗覆盖估计。
  • 作者建议对有疫苗记录者纳入回忆。
  • 作者建议插补缺失数据。
  • 作者建议在子样本中评估回忆与记录质量。
  • 作者建议进行敏感性分析。

局限性

  • 研究设计存在异质性。
  • 回忆数据纳入方式存在异质性。
  • 所测结局存在异质性。
  • 可靠性指标缺乏。
  • 无统一方法处理数据不完整。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

INTRODUCTION: High population coverage is key to the impact of vaccines. However, vaccine coverage estimates in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) have repeatedly been shown to be of poor quality. LMICs often rely on 'caregiver recall' of vaccination, the validity and collection method of which remains uncertain. We aimed to critique the quality of caregiver recall and make recommendations for its collection and use. METHODS: We performed a systematic review for methods assessing childhood vaccination coverage in LMICs. We searched Medline using variations of the key terms: (child) AND (vaccinat∗) AND (survey OR recall OR coverage) AND (reliab∗ OR valid∗). We selected articles assessing the quality of recall in LMICs and extracted reported validity, reliability and completeness. We synthesised recommendations on collecting, analysing and presenting caregiver recall for varying resource availabilities. RESULTS: Of 1268 articles, 134 full texts were screened and eight were included for review. There was heterogeneity in study designs, ways of incorporating recall data and outcomes measured. Sensitivity of recall was 41-98%; specificity was 12-80%. There was a dearth of reliability measures and no consistent method for dealing with data incompleteness. CONCLUSION: There are quality concerns with caregiver recall and difficulty in assessing it given the lack of a 'gold standard' for vaccine status. To improve coverage estimates and the impact of vaccines, caregiver recall should be used. Other recommendations include: recall is included for those presenting vaccine records; missing data is imputed; recall and record quality are assessed in a sub-sample; and sensitivity analyses are performed.

来源:Vaccine,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Modi RN, King C, Bar-Zeev N, et al. Caregiver recall in childhood vaccination surveys: Systematic review of recall quality and use in low- and middle-income settings. Vaccine. 2018. PMID: 29885771. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2018.05.089

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。