众包监测系统补充哨点流感网络的潜在价值:法国案例
研究评估了参与式监测系统GrippeNet.fr数据用于估计法国流感相关疾病发病率的效用,该系统自2012年起为在线队列,每周约5000名参与者报告流感疑似症状。不同病例定义产生的发病率估计与官方时间趋势吻合良好,对急性呼吸道感染(ARI)的准确性高于流感样病例(ILI),且常提前一周预测流感流行高峰。结论认为众包数据评估流行强度需基于连续多个季节的阈值估计,GrippeNet.fr在ARI监测于2014年停止后或可补充ILI哨点网络。
要点
- GrippeNet.fr发病率估计与官方时间趋势吻合良好,对ARI的准确性高于ILI。
- 流感流行高峰常被提前一周预测,尽管个体参与不规则。
- 欧洲疾病预防控制中心ILI定义应用于GrippeNet.fr数据时,追踪ARI优于追踪ILI。
核心结论
- 从众包数据评估流行强度需要基于连续多个季节的流行和强度阈值估计。
- 该研究提供了众包监测的标准化分析框架,在检测人群流感相关变化方面显示出高敏感性,有助于提高季节间及与哨点系统的疫情可比性。
- 在法国,GrippeNet.fr可在2014年ARI监测停止后补充ILI哨点网络。
研究设计与样本
- GrippeNet.fr为自2012年起建立的在线参与式监测队列,平均每周约5000名参与者报告提示流感的体征/症状。
- 采用基于报告体征/症状的不同病例定义,并纳入个体报告和参与情况的标准,产生流感相关疾病发病率估计,与哨点网络估计进行比较。
- 分析聚焦2012/13和2013/14两个季节,当时法国存在监测ILI和ARI的两个哨点网络。
主要发现
- GrippeNet.fr发病率估计与官方时间趋势吻合良好,对ARI的准确性高于ILI。
- 流感流行高峰常被提前一周预测,尽管个体参与不规则。
- 欧洲疾病预防控制中心ILI定义应用于GrippeNet.fr数据时,追踪ARI优于追踪ILI。
临床怎么用
- 在法国,GrippeNet.fr可在2014年ARI监测停止后补充ILI哨点网络(作者结论)。
局限性
- 从众包数据评估流行强度需要基于连续多个季节的流行和强度阈值估计。
- 个体参与不规则。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IntroductionParticipatory surveillance systems provide rich crowdsourced data, profiling individuals and their health status at a given time. We explored the usefulness of data from GrippeNet.fr, a participatory surveillance system, to estimate influenza-related illness incidence in France. Methods: GrippeNet.fr is an online cohort since 2012 averaging ca. 5,000 weekly participants reporting signs/symptoms suggestive of influenza. GrippeNet.fr has flexible criteria to define influenza-related illness. Different case definitions based on reported signs/symptoms and inclusions of criteria accounting for individuals' reporting and participation were used to produce influenza-related illness incidence estimates, which were compared to those from sentinel networks. We focused on the 2012/13 and 2013/14 seasons when two sentinel networks, monitoring influenza-like-illness (ILI) and acute respiratory infections (ARI) existed in France. Results: GrippeNet.fr incidence estimates agreed well with official temporal trends, with a higher accuracy for ARI than ILI. The influenza epidemic peak was often anticipated by one week, despite irregular participation of individuals. The European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control ILI definition, commonly used by participatory surveillance in Europe, performed better in tracking ARI than ILI when applied to GrippeNet.fr data. Conclusion: Evaluation of the epidemic intensity from crowdsourced data requires epidemic and intensity threshold estimations from several consecutive seasons. The study provides a standardised analytical framework for crowdsourced surveillance showing high sensitivity in detecting influenza-related changes in the population. It contributes to improve the comparability of epidemics across seasons and with sentinel systems. In France, GrippeNet.fr may supplement the ILI sentinel network after ARI surveillance discontinuation in 2014.
引用
- Guerrisi C, Turbelin C, Souty C, et al. The potential value of crowdsourced surveillance systems in supplementing sentinel influenza networks: the case of France. Euro Surveill. 2018. PMID: 29945696. doi:10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2018.23.25.1700337
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。