布基纳法索西南部常规扩大免疫规划冷链质量挑战:基于自动温度记录设备的评估
该研究在2015年对布基纳法索西部176个扩大免疫规划设施中随机抽取的25个卫生中心进行为期8个月的前瞻性冷链温度监测,使用自动温度记录设备并与常规温度记录器和疫苗瓶监测器比较。结果显示83%的冰箱出现异常温度,自动设备记录的异常小时记录远高于常规记录器和疫苗瓶监测器,冷链可靠性中位数为70%,作者建议在缺乏冷链基础设施更新或人员培训改善的情况下进行抗体应答评估。
要点
- 25个卫生中心中20/24(83%)的冰箱记录到异常温度,范围-18.5°C至+34.2°C。
- 自动设备记录低于+2°C的小时记录为12958/128905(10%),高于+8°C为7357/128905(5.7%)。
- 常规手动记录仅报告182/2761(7%)的不当温度,疫苗瓶监测器变色仅检测到133/2465(5%)的温度中断。
核心结论
- 布基纳法索西部常规免疫规划冷链可靠性存在重要问题,引发对疫苗效力的担忧。
- 在缺乏冷链基础设施系统性更新或人员培训与监测改善的情况下,作者建议进行抗体应答评估以研究有效免疫覆盖水平。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性评估2015年布基纳法索西部偏远地区冷链,随机抽取25个卫生中心,代表西部176个扩大免疫规划设施中的33%,监测8个月。
- 使用自动温度记录设备(Testostore 171-1©)监测,并与常规温度记录器和疫苗瓶监测器(VVM)比较。
主要发现
- 所有冰箱中位年龄为9年,10/25(42%)超过10年。
- 20/24(83%)的冰箱记录到不良温度,范围-18.5°C至+34.2°C。
- 低于+2°C的异常小时记录为12958/128905(10%),高于+8°C为7357/128905(5.7%)。
- 低温异常在00时至06时发生率更高(p < 0.001),高温异常在10-12时(p < 0.001)和13-16时(p < 0.001)发生率更高。
- 低于+2°C的异常温度持续1至24小时,高于+8°C持续13至24小时。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Abnormal temperatures are a major issue for vaccines within the Expanded Program of Immunization in tropical climates. Prolonged exposure to temperatures outside the standard +2 °C/+8 °C range can impact vaccine potency. METHODS: The current study used automatic temperature recording devices (Testostore 171-1©) to monitor cold chain in remote areas of Western Burkina Faso. A series of 25 randomly selected health centers representing 33% of the existing 176 EPI facilities in Western Burkina Faso were prospectively assessed for eight months in 2015. Automatic measurements were compared to routine temperature loggers and vaccine vial monitors (VVM). RESULTS: The median age for all refrigerators was 9 years with 10/25 (42%) older than 10 years. Adverse temperatures were recorded in 20/24 (83%) refrigerators and ranged from -18.5 °C to +34.2 °C with 12,958/128,905 (10%) abnormal hourly records below +2 °C and 7357/128,905 (5.7%) above +8 °C. Time of day significantly affected the rate of temperature excursions, with higher rates from 00 am to 06 am (p < 0.001) for low temperatures and 10-12 am (p < 0.001) and 13-16 pm (p < 0.001) for high temperatures. Abnormal temperatures lasted from 1 h to 24 h below +2 °C and 13-24 h above +8 °C. Standard manual registers reported only 182/2761 (7%) inadequate temperatures and VVM color change detected only 133/2465 (5%) disruptions. Reliability of the refrigerators ranged from 48% to 98.7% with a median of 70%. Risk factors for excursions were old age of the refrigerators, the months of April and May, hours of high activity during the day, and health staff-associated factors such as inappropriate actions or insufficient knowledge. CONCLUSION: Important cold chain reliability issues reported in the current study in Western Burkina Faso raise concern about vaccine potency. In the absence of systematic renewal of the cold chain infrastructure or improved staff training and monitoring, antibody response assessment is recommended to study levels of effective immunization coverage.
引用
- Sow C, Sanou C, Medah C, et al. Challenges of cold chain quality for routine EPI in south-west Burkina-Faso: An assessment using automated temperature recording devices. Vaccine. 2018. PMID: 29779921. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2018.05.062
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。