减少青少年疫苗接种期间疼痛和晕厥的试点干预可行性研究
在两家Kaiser Permanente西北儿科诊所开展为期3个月的试点研究,评估疫苗接种舒适菜单的可行性和可接受性。家长调查应答率为33%(378/1136),仅20%的家长报告提供者提供了舒适菜单。约50%被提供菜单的青少年选择了舒适物品,其中35%报告非常有助于改善接种体验,38%报告有些帮助。提供者访谈显示实施障碍包括缺乏时间和便利性以及试点期短暂。结论认为舒适菜单可能改善青少年接种体验并提高未来接种依从性,但需进一步研究确定更大规模实施的可行性及对减少不良事件的显著影响。
要点
- 家长调查应答率33%(378/1136),仅20%报告提供者提供了舒适菜单。
- 约50%被提供菜单的青少年选择舒适物品,35%认为非常有助于改善接种体验,38%认为有些帮助。
- 提供者访谈显示常见实施障碍包括缺乏时间和便利性以及试点期短暂。
核心结论
- 舒适菜单可能改善青少年疫苗接种体验并提高未来接种依从性,但仅20%的家长报告提供者提供了菜单。
- 需要进一步研究以确定更大规模实施该干预的可行性,并评估该干预是否对减少不良事件有显著影响。
研究设计与样本
- 在两家Kaiser Permanente西北儿科诊所开展为期3个月的试点研究,评估疫苗接种舒适菜单的可行性和可接受性。
- 舒适菜单提供多种舒适物品(如冷敷包、挤压球),儿童可在接种前选择。
- 调查最近接种疫苗青少年的家长并访谈提供者,以评估实施情况和干预效果。
主要发现
- 家长调查应答率为33%(378/1136)。
- 仅20%的家长报告提供者在接种访视期间提供了舒适菜单。
- 约50%被提供菜单的青少年选择了舒适物品,其中35%报告该物品对改善接种体验非常有帮助,38%报告有些帮助。
- 提供者访谈显示,实施该干预的常见障碍包括缺乏时间和便利性以及试点期短暂。
局限性
- 提供者访谈显示常见实施障碍包括缺乏时间和便利性以及试点期短暂。
- 仅20%的家长报告提供者在接种访视期间提供了舒适菜单。
- 需要进一步研究以确定更大规模实施该干预的可行性,并评估该干预是否对减少不良事件有显著影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Vaccines recommended for adolescents are considered safe and effective, however administration may occasionally result in acute pain at the injection site or syncope (fainting). These adverse effects pose a risk to patient safety and are potential barriers to adherence to future vaccinations. We assessed a novel intervention designed to help prevent acute pain and syncope associated with adolescent vaccinations. METHODS: We conducted a 3-month pilot study to assess the feasibility and acceptability of a vaccination comfort menu within two Kaiser Permanente Northwest pediatric clinics. The menu offered a variety of comfort items (e.g., cold packs, squeeze balls) that children could select prior to their vaccination. We surveyed parents of recently vaccinated adolescents and interviewed providers to assess the implementation and effectiveness of the intervention. RESULTS: Response rate for the parent survey was 33% (378/1136). Only 20% of the parents reported that their provider offered the comfort menu during the vaccination visit. Approximately 50% of the adolescents who were offered the menu selected a comfort item and most of these participants reported that the item was very (35%) or somewhat (38%) helpful in improving their vaccination experience. Per provider interviews, common barriers to implementing the intervention included lack of time and convenience, and the brevity of the pilot period. CONCLUSIONS: The comfort menu may improve the vaccination experience of youth and increase the likelihood of adherence with future vaccinations. However, only 20% of the parents reported that their provider offered the menu during the vaccination visit. Additional research is needed to determine the feasibility of implementing this intervention on a larger scale, as well as assessing whether the intervention has a significant impact on reducing adverse events.
引用
- Henninger ML, Kuntz JL, Firemark AJ, et al. Feasibility of a pilot intervention to reduce pain and syncope during adolescent vaccination. Vaccine. 2018. PMID: 29805090. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2018.05.070
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。