Facebook上疫苗接种辩论的极化现象
结果显示疫苗内容消费受回音室效应主导,极化逐年加剧,形成壁垒分明的社群,多数用户只接触支持或反对疫苗的信息而非两者兼有。作者认为回音室可解释准确信息宣传覆盖有限甚至适得其反,公共卫生专业人员应被动参与了解回音室内容以寻找有效应对反疫苗思维的方法。
要点
- 疫苗内容消费受回音室效应主导,极化随时间加剧。
- 多数用户只接触支持或反对疫苗的信息,而非两者兼有。
- 作者建议公共卫生专业人员被动参与社群以了解回音室内容。
核心结论
- 疫苗话题在Facebook上存在用户态度极化,且极化随年份增加。
- 回音室效应可能解释准确信息宣传覆盖有限、仅对亚组有效甚至加剧观点极化。
- 作者认为公共卫生专业人员应尝试了解这些回音室的内容,例如被动参与此类群组,才可能找到有效对抗反疫苗思维的方法。
研究设计与样本
- 应用社区检测算法自动检测基于用户页面活动形成的社群,并量化这些社群随时间的聚合度。
主要发现
- 疫苗相关内容消费由回音室效应主导,极化随年份增加。
- 用户消费习惯形成壁垒分明的社群,多数用户只消费支持或反对疫苗的信息,而非两者兼有。
- 将异议信息引入亚组会被忽视并可能产生反效果,从而强化亚组内原有观点。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为公共卫生专业人员应尝试了解这些回音室的内容,例如被动参与此类群组,才可能找到有效对抗反疫苗思维的方法。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Vaccine hesitancy has been recognized as a major global health threat. Having access to any type of information in social media has been suggested as a potential influence on the growth of anti-vaccination groups. Recent studies w.r.t. other topics than vaccination show that access to a wide amount of content through the Internet without intermediaries resolved into major segregation of the users in polarized groups. Users select information adhering to theirs system of beliefs and tend to ignore dissenting information. OBJECTIVES: The goal was to assess whether users' attitudes are polarized on the topic of vaccination on Facebook and how this polarization develops over time. METHODS: We perform a thorough quantitative analysis by studying the interaction of 2.6 M users with 298,018 Facebook posts over a time span of seven years and 5 months. We applied community detection algorithms to automatically detect the emergence of communities accounting for the users' activity on the pages. Also, we quantified the cohesiveness of these communities over time. RESULTS: Our findings show that the consumption of content about vaccines is dominated by the echo chamber effect and that polarization increased over the years. Well-segregated communities emerge from the users' consumption habits i.e., the majority of users consume information in favor or against vaccines, not both. CONCLUSION: The existence of echo chambers may explain why social-media campaigns that provide accurate information have limited reach and be effective only in sub-groups, even fomenting further opinion polarization. The introduction of dissenting information into a sub-group is disregarded and can produce a backfire effect, thus reinforcing the pre-existing opinions within the sub-group. Public health professionals should try to understand the contents of these echo chambers, for example by getting passively involved in such groups. Only then it will be possible to find effective ways of countering anti-vaccination thinking.
引用
- Schmidt AL, Zollo F, Scala A, et al. Polarization of the vaccination debate on Facebook. Vaccine. 2018. PMID: 29773322. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2018.05.040
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。