「我真的不太相信统计数据」——新加坡医护人员流感疫苗接受度的挑战
这项定性研究通过焦点小组讨论,识别并解释新加坡医护人员流感疫苗接受度受限的因素。研究纳入三所公立医院的73名医生、护士、联合卫生及辅助人员。结果显示,对疫苗安全性和有效性的恐惧、对已发表效力数据的不信任、对数据适用于新加坡的不确定性、对注射疼痛和过度用药的顾虑、对流感低风险的认知以及机构层面缺乏明确推广等因素共同限制了疫苗接受度。作者建议提供针对性的教育与沟通,并考虑按职业群体定制干预措施。
要点
- 对疫苗安全性和有效性的恐惧、对效力数据的不信任及对数据适用于新加坡的不确定性是主要障碍。
- 对注射疼痛、过度用药的顾虑、对流感低风险的认知及对替代防护措施的偏好也限制疫苗接受度。
- 机构领导层缺乏明确推广、医生群体疫苗犹豫及鼓励带病工作的文化构成机构层面障碍。
核心结论
- 研究发现个体层面存在对流感疫苗的误解和认知偏差,机构层面存在限制疫苗接受度的挑战。
- 作者认为亟需提供针对性的教育与沟通,建议广泛传播本地汇编的综合性材料以回应犹豫医护人员的具体关切。
- 作者建议考虑按职业群体定制干预措施,并优先解决医生群体的流感疫苗犹豫问题。
研究设计与样本
- 定性研究,采用焦点小组讨论。
- 纳入新加坡三所公立医院的73名医生、护士、联合卫生及辅助人员。
主要发现
- 识别出的挑战包括:因疫苗安全性和有效性负面轶事而加剧的对接种后感染流感的恐惧、对已发表效力数据的不信任、对现有数据适用于新加坡的不确定性。
- 其他挑战包括:不愿引入化学物质或过度用药、注射疼痛、对流感低风险的认知、对流感传播认识有限及偏好替代性患者保护措施。
- 不同职业群体间态度存在差异。
- 部分机构领导层缺乏明确推广、感知到医生群体疫苗犹豫、可及性问题及隐式鼓励带病工作的文化构成进一步障碍。
临床怎么用
- 作者建议提供广泛传播的、本地汇编的综合性材料,以回应犹豫医护人员 specific 的关切,而非仅提供更多数据。
- 作者建议考虑按职业群体定制干预措施。
- 作者认为机构规范和文化可能对设定默认行为有强大影响,需努力改善部分机构的流感疫苗推广和优先级。
- 作者建议将疫苗相关沟通与其他感染控制沟通整合,并优先解决医生群体的流感疫苗犹豫。
- 作者认为在新加坡进一步研究应对影响流感疫苗接受度认知偏差的策略是可取的。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Influenza vaccine acceptance among healthcare workers (HCWs) is a worldwide problem, but relatively little research has focussed on Asia, including Singapore. Despite widespread access and recommendations from public health authorities, influenza vaccine uptake remains suboptimal among HCWs. METHODS: Our qualitative study used focus group discussions to identify and explain factors limiting influenza vaccine acceptance among HCWs in Singapore. A total of 73 doctors, nurses, allied health and ancillary staff across three public hospitals were included. RESULTS: Challenges identified include a fear of contracting influenza from vaccination exacerbated by negative anecdotes regarding vaccine safety and efficacy, distrust of published efficacy data, uncertainty regarding relevance of existing data for Singapore, reluctance to introduce chemicals or overmedicate, pain from injection, low risk attributed to influenza and limited awareness of influenza transmission with a preference for alternatives in patient protection. Differences in attitudes were observed across vocational groups. Lack of overt promotion by hospital leadership in some institutions, perceived vaccine hesitancy among doctors, access, and work culture that implicitly encourages working through illness were further barriers. CONCLUSION: Our findings highlight a combination of misperceptions about influenza vaccination and cognitive biases at the individual level, and challenges at the institutional level limiting uptake. Findings indicate an urgent need to provide targeted education and communication. Rather than providing more data, we recommend a widely-disseminated, locally-compiled synthesis addressing specific concerns of hesitant HCWs. Tailoring interventions to specific vocational groups should be considered. Institutional norms and culture may have a powerful influence in setting default behaviours: more effort is needed in improving influenza vaccine promotion and priority at some institutions, integrating vaccine-related communication with other infection control communication and addressing influenza vaccine hesitancy among doctors as a priority. Finally, further study of strategies to address cognitive biases affecting influenza vaccine acceptance in Singapore is desirable.
引用
- Sundaram N, Duckett K, Yung CF, et al. "I wouldn't really believe statistics" - Challenges with influenza vaccine acceptance among healthcare workers in Singapore. Vaccine. 2018. PMID: 29519593. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2018.02.102
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。