口服与肠外疫苗包装形式的商品成本与总交付成本
研究基于专家信息、已发表文献和肯尼亚多年免疫规划,构建口服与肠外疫苗包装形式的商品成本(COGS)和总交付成本(TCOD)模型,以轮状病毒疫苗和灭活脊髓灰质炎疫苗(IPV)为代表。结果显示口服疫苗中吹灌封多单剂量安瓿成本最低,肠外疫苗中十剂玻璃瓶成本最低,聚合物容器值得进一步考虑。
要点
- 口服疫苗中吹灌封多单剂量安瓿COGS为每剂0.12美元,低于单剂玻璃瓶的每剂0.40美元。
- 口服疫苗中吹灌封多单剂量安瓿TCOD为每剂 delivered 1.19美元,低于十剂玻璃瓶的1.61美元。
- 肠外疫苗中十剂玻璃瓶COGS和TCOD均最低,分别为每剂0.22美元和每剂 delivered 1.56美元。
核心结论
- 鉴于聚合物容器有潜力解决玻璃包装的局限性并降低COGS和TCOD,值得进一步考虑作为疫苗包装的替代方案。
研究设计与样本
- 基于专家信息、已发表文献和肯尼亚多年免疫规划构建口服与肠外疫苗包装形式的COGS和TCOD模型,以轮状病毒疫苗和IPV分别代表口服和肠外疫苗。
主要发现
- 口服疫苗包装中吹灌封多单剂量安瓿COGS最低,为每剂0.12美元,单剂玻璃瓶为每剂0.40美元。
- 口服疫苗包装中吹灌封多单剂量安瓿TCOD最低,为每剂 delivered 1.19美元,十剂玻璃瓶为每剂 delivered 1.61美元。
- 肠外疫苗包装中十剂玻璃瓶COGS最低,为每剂0.22美元,预成型CPAD装置最高,为每剂0.60美元。
- 肠外疫苗包装中十剂玻璃瓶TCOD最低,为每剂 delivered 1.56美元;聚合物容器中吹灌封多单剂量安瓿TCOD最低,为每剂 delivered 1.89美元,预成型CPAD装置最高,为每剂 delivered 2.25美元。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Despite limitations of glass packaging for vaccines, the industry has been slow to implement alternative formats. Polymer containers may address many of these limitations, such as breakage and delamination. However, the ability of polymer containers to achieve cost of goods sold (COGS) and total cost of delivery (TCOD) competitive with that of glass containers is unclear, especially for cost-sensitive low- and lower-middle-income countries. COGS and TCOD models for oral and parenteral vaccine packaging formats were developed based on information from subject matter experts, published literature, and Kenya's comprehensive multiyear plan for immunization. Rotavirus and inactivated poliovirus vaccines (IPV) were used as representative examples of oral and parenteral vaccines, respectively. Packaging technologies evaluated included glass vials, blow-fill-seal (BFS) containers, preformed polymer containers, and compact prefilled auto-disable (CPAD) devices in both BFS and preformed formats. For oral vaccine packaging, BFS multi-monodose (MMD) ampoules were the least expensive format, with a COGS of $0.12 per dose. In comparison, oral single-dose glass vials had a COGS of $0.40. BFS MMD ampoules had the lowest TCOD of oral vaccine containers at $1.19 per dose delivered, and ten-dose glass vials had a TCOD of $1.61 per dose delivered. For parenteral vaccines, the lowest COGS was achieved with ten-dose glass vials at $0.22 per dose. In contrast, preformed CPAD devices had the highest COGS at $0.60 per dose. Ten-dose glass vials achieved the lowest TCOD of the parenteral vaccine formats at $1.56 per dose delivered. Of the polymer containers for parenteral vaccines, BFS MMD ampoules achieved the lowest TCOD at $1.89 per dose delivered, whereas preformed CPAD devices remained the most expensive format, at $2.25 per dose delivered. Given their potential to address the limitations of glass and reduce COGS and TCOD, polymer containers deserve further consideration as alternative approaches for vaccine packaging.
引用
- Sedita J, Perrella S, Morio M, et al. Cost of goods sold and total cost of delivery for oral and parenteral vaccine packaging formats. Vaccine. 2018. PMID: 29449099. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2018.01.011
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。