反疫苗接种与支持补充替代医学的态度均反映对健康的魔法信念
该横断面在线调查纳入2697名澳大利亚成年人,考察补充替代医学(CAM)使用与疫苗接种怀疑的关系,以及整体健康和魔法健康信念量表(HHB、MHB)能否解释该关系。CAM与反疫苗接种主要在态度层面相关(r=-0.437),健康世界观(HHB和MHB)解释了二者协方差的43.1%,MHB是最强预测因子。作者认为疫苗怀疑反映一种贬低科学知识、偏好魔法或迷信思维的 broader 健康世界观,反映该世界观的劝说信息可能比事实宣传更有效。
要点
- CAM与反疫苗接种态度相关(r=-0.437),未发现CAM从业者影响客户所致。
- 健康世界观(HHB和MHB)解释CAM与疫苗接种态度协方差的43.1%。
- MHB是CAM和疫苗接种态度的最强预测因子。
核心结论
- 疫苗怀疑反映一种贬低科学知识、偏好魔法或迷信思维的 broader 健康世界观。
- 反映该世界观的劝说信息可能比事实宣传更有效。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面在线调查,纳入2697名澳大利亚成年人。
- 调查包括人口学、CAM和疫苗接种测量,以及整体健康信念量表(HHB)和魔法健康信念量表(MHB)。
主要发现
- CAM与反疫苗接种主要在态度层面相关(r=-0.437)。
- 未发现CAM从业者影响客户导致该关联的证据。
- 路径分析显示健康世界观(HHB和MHB)解释了CAM与疫苗接种态度协方差的43.1%。
- 在包含人口学预测因子的回归中,MHB是CAM和疫苗接种态度的最强预测因子。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,反映该世界观的劝说信息可能比事实宣传更有效。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
We examined the relationship between complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) use and vaccination scepticism; and specifically whether a person's more general health-related worldview might explain this relationship. A cross-sectional online survey of adult Australians (N = 2697) included demographic, CAM, and vaccination measures, as well as the holistic and magical health belief scales (HHB, MHB). HHB emphasises links between mind and body health, and the impact of general 'wellness' on specific ailments or resistance to disease, whilst MHB specifically taps ontological confusions and cognitive errors about health. CAM and anti-vaccination were found to be linked primarily at the attitudinal level (r = -0.437). We did not find evidence that this was due to CAM practitioners influencing their clients. Applying a path-analytic approach, we found that individuals' health worldview (HHB and MHB) accounted for a significant proportion (43.1%) of the covariance between CAM and vaccination attitudes. MHB was by far the strongest predictor of both CAM and vaccination attitudes in regressions including demographic predictors. We conclude that vaccination scepticism reflects part of a broader health worldview that discounts scientific knowledge in favour of magical or superstitious thinking. Therefore, persuasive messages reflecting this worldview may be more effective than fact-based campaigns in influencing vaccine sceptics.
引用
- Bryden GM, Browne M, Rockloff M, et al. Anti-vaccination and pro-CAM attitudes both reflect magical beliefs about health. Vaccine. 2018. PMID: 29395527. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2017.12.068
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。