急性弛缓性脊髓炎(AFM)与肠道病毒D68(EV-D68)之间的关联——因果关系的证据是什么?
该研究利用已发表文献和灰色文献,应用Bradford Hill因果推断标准评估EV-D68与急性弛缓性脊髓炎(AFM)的因果关系。结果显示,九条标准中六条完全满足、两条部分满足、生物学梯度标准最低限度满足;系统发育流行病学显示自2000年以来演化出基因独特的暴发株clade B1,该株与AFM相关并在动物模型中具有神经致病性。作者认为,尽管剂量-反应关系仍需更多研究,Bradford Hill标准的应用支持EV-D68与AFM之间存在因果关系。
要点
- 九条Bradford Hill标准中,六条完全满足、两条部分满足、生物学梯度仅最低限度满足。
- EV-D68感染发病率在全球范围内呈上升趋势。
- 自2000年以来演化出基因独特的暴发株clade B1,该株与AFM相关,并在动物模型中具有神经致病性。
核心结论
- 尽管剂量-反应关系仍需更多研究,Bradford Hill标准的应用支持EV-D68与AFM之间存在因果关系。
研究设计与样本
- 利用已发表文献和灰色文献的数据,应用Bradford Hill九条因果推断标准评估EV-D68与AFM的因果关系。
- 根据现有证据,将每条Bradford Hill标准判定为未满足、最低限度满足、部分满足或完全满足。
主要发现
- 应用于EV-D68与AFM的现有证据显示,九条Bradford Hill标准中六条完全满足、两条部分满足。
- 生物学梯度标准为最低限度满足。
- EV-D68感染发病率在全球范围内呈上升趋势。
- 系统发育流行病学显示自2000年以来从原始Fermon和Rhyne株发生 diversification,演化出基因独特的暴发株clade B1。
- clade B1(而非较老的毒株)与AFM相关,并在动物模型中具有神经致病性。
关键数值与推荐
- Bradford Hill标准:六条完全满足、两条部分满足、生物学梯度最低限度满足。
局限性
- 剂量-反应关系仍需更多研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BackgroundEnterovirus D68 (EV-D68) has historically been a sporadic disease, causing occasional small outbreaks of generally mild infection. In recent years, there has been evidence of an increase in EV-D68 infections globally. Large outbreaks of EV-D68, with thousands of cases, occurred in the United States, Canada and Europe in 2014. The outbreaks were associated temporally and geographically with an increase in clusters of acute flaccid myelitis (AFM). Aims: We aimed to evaluate a causal association between EV-D68 and AFM. Methods: Using data from the published and grey literature, we applied the Bradford Hill criteria, a set of nine principles applied to examine causality, to evaluate the relationship between EV-D68 and AFM. Based on available evidence, we defined the Bradford Hill Criteria as being not met, or met minimally, partially or fully. Results: Available evidence applied to EV-D68 and AFM showed that six of the Bradford Hill criteria were fully met and two were partially met. The criterion of biological gradient was minimally met. The incidence of EV-D68 infections is increasing world-wide. Phylogenetic epidemiology showed diversification from the original Fermon and Rhyne strains since the year 2000, with evolution of a genetically distinct outbreak strain, clade B1. Clade B1, but not older strains, is associated with AFM and is neuropathic in animal models. Conclusion: While more research is needed on dose-response relationship, application of the Bradford Hill criteria supported a causal relationship between EV-D68 and AFM.
引用
- Dyda A, Stelzer-Braid S, Adam D, et al. The association between acute flaccid myelitis (AFM) and Enterovirus D68 (EV-D68) - what is the evidence for causation? Euro Surveill. 2018. PMID: 29386095. doi:10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2018.23.3.17-00310
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。