社会影响债券作为健康与社会项目筹资方法:潜在关注领域
社会影响债券(SIBs)是一种新的社会服务与健康促进项目筹资方式,由投资者 upfront 投入资本,项目达标后政府还本付息。本文基于对健康与社会服务市场化改革及SIBs演进的相关文献,识别并探讨了SIBs的若干关注领域,包括政府成本增加、项目范围受限、政策制定碎片化、公共部门服务供给被削弱、社会问题根源被误读以及系统性脆弱性被固化。作者认为,评估SIBs对公共卫生的潜在贡献必须考虑其长期、总体和情境化效应,且此类评估应探讨支持SIBs的「常识」论点背后的假设。
要点
- SIBs由投资者 upfront 出资,项目达到预定成功标准后政府向投资者还本付息。
- 关注领域包括政府成本增加、项目范围受限、政策制定碎片化及公共部门服务供给被削弱。
- 作者认为评估SIBs须考虑长期、总体和情境化效应,并探讨支持其「常识」论点背后的假设。
核心结论
- 作者认为,必须考虑SIBs的长期、总体和情境化效应,以评估其促进公共卫生的潜力。
- 作者结论指出,此类评估必须探讨常用于支持SIBs的「常识」论点背后的假设。
研究设计与样本
- 本文从考察健康与社会服务市场化改革及SIBs筹资机制演进的文献中,识别并探讨SIBs的相关关注领域。
主要发现
- SIBs于2010年在英国引入,此后在美国和欧洲各地实施,并在其他司法管辖区有一定采用。
- 关注领域包括政府成本增加、项目范围受限、政策制定碎片化、公共部门服务供给被削弱、社会问题根源被误读以及系统性脆弱性被固化。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Social Impact Bonds (SIBs) represent a new way to finance social service and health promotion programs whereby different types of investors provide an upfront investment of capital. If a given program meets predetermined criteria for a successful outcome, the government pays back investors with interest. Introduced in the United Kingdom in 2010, SIBs have since been implemented in the United States and across Europe, with some uptake in other jurisdictions. We identify and explore selected areas of concern related to SIBs, drawing from literature examining market-based reforms to health and social services and the evolution of the SIB funding mechanism. These areas of concern include increased costs to governments, restricted program scope, fragmented policymaking, undermining of public-sector service provision, mischaracterization of the root causes of social problems, and entrenchment of systemically produced vulnerabilities. We argue that it is essential to consider the long-term, aggregate, and contextualized effects of SIBs in order to evaluate their potential to contribute to public health. We conclude that such evaluations must explore the assumptions underlying the "common sense" arguments often used in support of SIBs.
引用
- Katz AS, Brisbois B, Zerger S, et al. Social Impact Bonds as a Funding Method for Health and Social Programs: Potential Areas of Concern. Am J Public Health. 2017. PMID: 29267055. doi:10.2105/AJPH.2017.304157
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。