一项集群随机试验:新型数字吊坠与语音提醒平台对提高印度乌代布尔农村婴儿免疫接种依从性的效果
在印度乌代布尔农村开展集群随机对照试验,将96个村庄卫生营地随机分为3组:NFC贴纸组、NFC吊坠组、NFC吊坠加当地方言语音提醒组,评估对婴儿DTP3依从性的效果。结果显示,三项主要结局的组间差异在控制混杂因素前后均无统计学显著性;过程结局提示吊坠引发社区讨论、用户满意度高且家庭内可见度增加。
要点
- 在两项DTP3依从性结局中,对照组(贴纸)的点估计值高于两个干预组。
- 在注册后两个月内完成DTP3的结局中,两个干预组的点估计值高于对照组。
- 所有主要结局的组间差异在控制混杂因素前后均无统计学显著性。
核心结论
- NFC吊坠或加语音提醒的吊坠均未直接提高婴儿至DTP3的免疫接种及时性这一主要结局。
- 过程结局提示,具有文化象征意义的吊坠有潜力成为免疫接种活动的辅助工具。
- 后续工作将在产前阶段开始使用该平台,在连续性照护框架下检验能否促进对疫苗的积极行为改变。
研究设计与样本
- 在印度乌代布尔地区由Seva Mandir提供服务的5个区块内开展集群随机对照试验。
- 2015年8月至2016年4月期间,将96个村庄卫生营地随机分为3组:NFC贴纸组、NFC吊坠组、NFC吊坠加当地方言语音提醒组。
- 主要结局为DTP1接种后两个月内两次卫生营地内完成DTP3的依从性、出生后180天内完成DTP3的依从性、注册后两个月内完成DTP3的依从性。
主要发现
- DTP1后两次营地内完成DTP3:对照组(贴纸)74.2% vs 吊坠组67.2% vs 吊坠加语音组69.3%。
- 出生后180天内完成DTP3:对照组(贴纸)69.4% vs 吊坠组57.4% vs 吊坠加语音组58.7%。
- 注册后两个月内完成DTP3:吊坠组37.7% vs 吊坠加语音组38.7% vs 对照组(贴纸)27.4%。
- 所有主要结局的依从性差异在控制混杂因素前后均无统计学显著性。
- 提供项链引发显著社区讨论(H=8.8796,df=2,p=.0118),用户满意度高(χ2=26.039,df=4,p<.0001),家庭内可见度增加(祖母:χ2=34.023,df=2,p<.0001;父亲:χ2=34.588,df=2,p<.0001)。
局限性
- 所有主要结局的依从性差异在控制混杂因素前后均无统计学显著性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Five hundred thousand children under the age of 5 die from vaccine preventable diseases in India every year. More than just improving coverage, increasing timeliness of immunizations is critical to ensuring infant health in the first year of life. Novel, culturally appropriate community engagement strategies are worth exploring to close the immunization gap. In our study, a digital NFC (Near Field Communication) pendant worn on black thread and voice call reminder system was tested for the effectiveness in improving DTP3 adherence within 2 monthly camps from DTP1 administration. METHOD: A cluster randomized controlled trial was conducted in which 96 village health camps were randomized to 3 arms: NFC sticker, NFC pendant, and NFC pendant with voice call reminder in local dialect. Randomization was done across 5 blocks in the Udaipur District serviced by Seva Mandir from August 2015 to April 2016. RESULTS: In terms of our three primary outcomes related to DTP3 adherence, point estimates show conflicting results. Two outcomes presented adherence in the control. DTP3 completion within two camps after DTP1 showed higher adherence in the Control (Sticker) (74.2%) arm compared to the Pendant (67.2%) and Pendant and Voice arms (69.3%). Likewise, the estimate for DTP3 completion within 180 days of birth in the Control (Sticker) (69.4%) arm was higher than estimates in the Pendant (57.4%) and Pendant and Voice arms (58.7%). However, one outcome displayed higher adherence in the intervention. DTP3 completion within two months from the time of registration was higher in the Pendant (37.7%) and Pendant and Voice arms (38.7%) compared to the Control (Sticker) arm (27.4%). In all primary outcomes, differences in adherence were statistically insignificant both before and after controlling for confounding factors. In terms of secondary outcomes, our results suggest that providing a necklace generated significant community discussion (H = 8.8796, df = 2, p = .0118), had strong satisfaction among users (χ2=26.039, df = 4, p < .0001), and resulted in increased visibility within families (grandmothers:χ2=34.023, df = 2, p < .0001, fathers: χ2=34.588, df = 2, p < .0001). CONCLUSION: Neither the NFC necklace nor the necklace with additional voice call reminders in the local dialect directly resulted in an increase in infant immunization timeliness through DTP3, the primary outcome. Still our process outcomes suggest that our culturally symbolic necklace has potential to be an assistive tool in immunization campaigns. Follow-on work will seek to examine whether positive behavior change towards vaccines can be fostered with earlier engagement of this platform beginning in the prenatal stage, under a continuum of care framework.
引用
- Nagar R, Venkat P, Stone LD, et al. A cluster randomized trial to determine the effectiveness of a novel, digital pendant and voice reminder platform on increasing infant immunization adherence in rural Udaipur, India. Vaccine. 2017. PMID: 29162321. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2017.11.023
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。