国家免疫信息系统评估——肯尼亚2015年与加纳2016年
2015年和2016年,采用世界卫生组织(WHO)与美国疾控中心(CDC)新开发的评估方法,在肯尼亚和加纳开展免疫信息系统评估,以识别免疫数据质量问题的根本原因并推动改进计划。两国共同面临的数据质量挑战包括对机构级目标人口数据信心低(肯尼亚=50%,加纳=53%)以及儿童登记册与机构汇总表之间数据一致性差(肯尼亚=0%,加纳=3%)。基于评估结果的数据质量改进计划正在两国实施。
要点
- 肯尼亚和加纳采用WHO与CDC新方法评估免疫信息系统,识别数据质量问题的根本原因。
- 两国共同挑战:机构级目标人口数据信心低(肯尼亚=50%,加纳=53%),登记册与汇总表一致性差(肯尼亚=0%,加纳=3%)。
- 基于评估结果的数据质量改进计划正在两国实施。
核心结论
- 免疫信息系统评估可帮助国家识别和解决免疫数据质量差的根本原因,为未来免疫规划投资提供更强的证据基础。
研究设计与样本
- 2015年和2016年分别在肯尼亚和加纳开展免疫信息系统评估(IISAs),采用WHO与CDC新设计的评估方法,旨在识别免疫数据质量问题的根本原因并促进改进计划制定。
主要发现
- 两国共同的数据质量挑战包括对机构级目标人口数据信心低(肯尼亚=50%,加纳=53%)以及儿童登记册与机构汇总表之间数据一致性差(肯尼亚=0%,加纳=3%)。
- 肯尼亚的系统性挑战包括支持性督导有限以及缺乏访问电子报告系统的资源。
- 加纳的挑战包括次县级行政层级定义不清。
关键数值与推荐
- 对机构级目标人口数据信心:肯尼亚=50%,加纳=53%。
- 儿童登记册与机构汇总表数据一致性:肯尼亚=0%,加纳=3%。
临床怎么用
- 基于评估结果的数据质量改进计划正在肯尼亚和加纳两国实施。
- 免疫信息系统评估可帮助国家识别和解决免疫数据质量差的根本原因,为未来免疫规划投资提供更强的证据基础。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The collection, analysis, and use of data to measure and improve immunization program performance are priorities for the World Health Organization (WHO), global partners, and national immunization programs (NIPs). High quality data are essential for evidence-based decision-making to support successful NIPs. Consistent recording and reporting practices, optimal access to and use of health information systems, and rigorous interpretation and use of data for decision-making are characteristics of high-quality immunization information systems. In 2015 and 2016, immunization information system assessments (IISAs) were conducted in Kenya and Ghana using a new WHO and CDC assessment methodology designed to identify root causes of immunization data quality problems and facilitate development of plans for improvement. Data quality challenges common to both countries included low confidence in facility-level target population data (Kenya = 50%, Ghana = 53%) and poor data concordance between child registers and facility tally sheets (Kenya = 0%, Ghana = 3%). In Kenya, systemic challenges included limited supportive supervision and lack of resources to access electronic reporting systems; in Ghana, challenges included a poorly defined subdistrict administrative level. Data quality improvement plans (DQIPs) based on assessment findings are being implemented in both countries. IISAs can help countries identify and address root causes of poor immunization data to provide a stronger evidence base for future investments in immunization programs.
引用
- Scott C, Clarke KEN, Grevendonk J, et al. Country Immunization Information System Assessments - Kenya, 2015 and Ghana, 2016. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 2017. PMID: 29121004. doi:10.15585/mmwr.mm6644a5
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。