阿富汗残疾人全民健康覆盖进展评估:基于重复横断面调查的多水平分析
研究利用阿富汗13个省份2005年和2013年两次代表性家庭调查数据,采用多水平模型分析残疾人感知的医疗服务可及性与覆盖体验变化。结果显示,感知服务可及性从2005年227人(69%)降至2013年405人(44%),正向覆盖体验从255人(78%)降至410人(45%),均p<0·0001,偏远村庄影响尤为明显。
要点
- 2005年调查334人,2013年调查961人,均为残疾人。
- 感知服务可及性从227人(69%)降至405人(44%),p<0·0001。
- 正向覆盖体验从255人(78%)降至410人(45%),p<0·0001。
核心结论
- 阿富汗残疾人感知的医疗可及性与覆盖体验未显著改善,偏远地区尤为突出。
- 阿富汗卫生政策需应对态度、社会和可及性障碍。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为重复横断面调查的多水平分析,使用2005年和2013年阿富汗13个省份的两项代表性家庭调查数据。
- 2005年调查纳入334人,2013年调查纳入961人,调查内容包括活动受限与功能困难、社会经济因素、感知医疗可及性及医疗需求覆盖体验。
主要发现
- 2005年至2013年,残疾人平均年龄、就业和资产水平略有增加,但教育水平下降。
- 正规教育和较高资产水平与感知医疗可及性改善及正向覆盖体验相关,就业仅与正向覆盖体验相关。
- 感知服务可及性从2005年227人(69%)降至2013年405人(44%),p<0·0001。
- 正向覆盖体验从2005年255人(78%)降至2013年410人(45%),p<0·0001。
- 2013年村庄偏远程度增加:无铺装道路连接从2005年186人(57%)升至2013年797人(87%),p<0·0001;到达医疗机构平均时间从64·3分钟(SD 167·7)升至84·4分钟(SD 107·7),p<0·0001;偏远程度对感知医疗可及性有负面影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Since 2002, Afghanistan has made much effort to achieve universal health coverage. According to the UN Sustainable Development Goal 3, target eight, the provision of quality care to all must include usually underserved groups, including people with disabilities. We investigated whether a decade of international investment in the Afghan health system has brought quality health care to this group. METHODS: We used data from two representative household surveys, one done in 2005 and one in 2013, in 13 provinces of Afghanistan, that included questions about activity limitations and functioning difficulties, socioeconomic factors, perceived availability of health care, and experience with coverage of health-care needs. We used multilevel modelling and tests for interaction to investigate factors associated with differences in perception between timepoints and whether village remoteness affected changes in perception. FINDINGS: The 2005 survey included 334 people, and the 2013 survey included 961 people. Mean age, employment, and asset levels of participants with disabilities increased slightly between 2005 and 2013, but the level of education decreased. Formal education and higher asset level were associated with improved availability of health care and positive experience with coverage of health-care needs, whereas being employed was only associated with the latter. Perceived availability of health care and positive experience with coverage of health-care needs significantly worsened in 2013 compared with in 2005 (227 [69%] perceived that services were available in 2005 vs 405 [44%] in 2013, p<0·0001; 255 [78%] perceived a positive experience in 2005 vs 410 [45%] in 2013, p<0·0001). Village remoteness increased in 2013 (no connectivity by paved road 186 [57%] in 2005 vs 797 [87%] in 2013, p<0·0001; mean time to reach health-care facility 64·3 min [SD 167·7] vs 84·4 min [107·7], p<0·0001) and negatively affected perception of health-care availability. INTERPRETATION: Perceived availability of health care and experience with health-care coverage have not greatly improved for people with disabilities in Afghanistan, particularly in remote areas. Health policy in Afghanistan will need to address attitudinal, social, and accessibility barriers to health care. FUNDING: Swedish International Development Agency.
引用
- Trani JF, Kumar P, Ballard E, et al. Assessment of progress towards universal health coverage for people with disabilities in Afghanistan: a multilevel analysis of repeated cross-sectional surveys. Lancet Glob Health. 2017. PMID: 28716353. doi:10.1016/S2214-109X(17)30251-6
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。