文献速递卫生政策与健康促进

灾难应对的伦理指导,特别是危机护理标准方面:一项系统综述

Ethical Guidance for Disaster Response, Specifically Around Crisis Standards of Care: A Systematic Review.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Public Health · 2017-07-20

该研究系统检索2012至2016年PubMed、Google Scholar和ISI Web of Science中讨论危机护理标准伦理指导的同行评议文章,580篇中38篇(6%)符合标准。作者主要关注危机护理标准的伦理依据、分诊的伦理依据及国际问题,并指出伦理指导须切实可行且应提前于灾难规划。

要点

  • 580篇提及伦理与危机护理标准或灾难规划的文章中,38篇(6%)符合选择标准。
  • 作者主要关注危机护理标准的伦理依据(n=20)以及分诊的伦理依据(n=19)。
  • 美国危机护理标准计划很少实施,而美国以外国家更常在自然灾害或人道主义危机应对中实施。

核心结论

  • 本系统综述识别了灾难规划中围绕危机护理标准最常用和讨论最多的伦理概念与原则。
  • 多数实质性伦理讨论集中于分诊以及灾难应对为何需要伦理,关于健康公平等更细致问题的讨论虽存在但较少。
  • 伦理指导须切实可行且可实施,伦理框架应指导临床方案,但需伦理分析明确策略以兑现伦理承诺并实现伦理目标。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述,检索PubMed、Google Scholar和ISI Web of Science从2012年至2016年的学术文献。
  • 纳入标准为实质性讨论危机护理标准伦理指导的同行评议文章。
  • 研究人员筛选潜在文章以识别和讨论危机护理标准规划中的伦理问题,并对伦理概念和原则进行分类编目。

主要发现

  • 580篇提及伦理与危机护理标准或灾难规划的同行评议文章中,38篇(6%)符合选择标准。
  • 作者主要关注危机护理标准的伦理依据(n=20)、分诊的伦理依据(n=19)以及国际问题(n=17)。
  • 文献还讨论了其他伦理问题,包括照护义务(n=11)、规划义务概念(n=8)、功利主义(n=5)、道德困扰(n=4)、专业规范(n=3)、互惠(n=2)、分配标准(n=4)、公平(n=4)、研究伦理(n=2)、资源管理义务(n=2)、社会效用与社会价值(n=2)及其他(n=20)。
  • 美国危机护理标准计划迄今很少实施,尽管某些组成部分常见(如美国急诊科定期使用分诊)。
  • 美国以外国家更常在自然灾害或人道主义危机应对中实施危机护理标准。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Terrorism, disease outbreaks, and other natural disasters and mass casualty events have pushed health care and public health systems to identify and refine emergency preparedness protocols for disaster response. Ethical guidance, alongside legal and medical frameworks, are increasingly common components of disaster response plans. OBJECTIVES: To systematically review the prevalence and content of ethical guidance offered for disaster response, specifically around crisis standards of care (CSCs). SEARCH METHODS: We systematically indexed academic literature from PubMed, Google Scholar, and ISI Web of Science from 2012 to 2016. SELECTION CRITERIA: We searched for peer-reviewed articles that substantively engaged in discussion of ethical guidance for CSCs. DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS: Researchers screened potential articles for identification and discussion of ethical issues in CSC planning. We categorized and cataloged ethical concepts and principles. MAIN RESULTS: Of 580 peer-reviewed articles mentioning ethics and CSCs or disaster planning, 38 (6%) met selection criteria. The systematic review of the CSC ethics literature since 2012 showed that authors were primarily focused on the ethical justifications for CSC (n = 20) as well as a need for ethics guidelines for implementing CSCs; the ethical justifications for triage (n = 19), both as to which criteria to use and the appropriate processes by which to employ triage; and international issues (n = 17). In addition to these areas of focus, the scholarly literature included discussion of a number of other ethical issues, including duty to care (n = 11), concepts of a duty to plan (n = 8), utilitarianism (n = 5), moral distress (n = 4), professional norms (n = 3), reciprocity (n = 2), allocation criteria (n = 4), equity (n = 4), research ethics (n = 2), duty to steward resources (n = 2), social utility and social worth (n = 2), and a number of others (n = 20). Although public health preparedness efforts have paid increasing attention to CSCs in recent years, CSC plans have rarely been implemented within the United States to date, although some components are common (e.g., triage is used in US emergency departments regularly). Conversely, countries outside the United States more commonly implement CSCs within a natural disaster or humanitarian crisis response, and may offer significant insight into ethics and disaster response for US-based practitioners. CONCLUSIONS: This systematic review identifies the most oft-used and -discussed ethical concepts and principles used in disaster planning around CSCs. Although discussion of more nuanced issues (e.g., health equity) are present, the majority of items substantively engaging in ethical discussion around disaster planning do so regarding triage and why ethics is needed in disaster response generally. Public health implications. A significant evolution in disaster planning has occurred within the past decade; ethical theories and frameworks have been put to work. For ethical guidance to be useful, it must be practical and implementable. Although high-level, abstract frameworks were once prevalent in disaster planning-especially in the early days of pandemic planning-concerns about the ethically difficult concept of CSCs pervade scholarly articles. Ethical norms must be clearly stated and justified and practical guidelines ought to follow from them. Ethical frameworks should guide clinical protocols, but this requires that ethical analysis clarifies what strategies to use to honor ethical commitments and achieve ethical objectives. Such implementation issues must be considered well ahead of a disaster. As governments and health care systems plan for mass casualty events, ethical guidance that is theoretically sound and practically useful can-and should-form an important foundation from which to build practical guidance for responding to disasters with morally appropriate means.

来源:Am J Public Health,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Leider JP, DeBruin D, Reynolds N, et al. Ethical Guidance for Disaster Response, Specifically Around Crisis Standards of Care: A Systematic Review. Am J Public Health. 2017. PMID: 28727521. doi:10.2105/AJPH.2017.303882

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。